Deep Water research

Coffee Extraction and Acidity Trade-offs

Report generation has finished.

You are reading the full report.

How do brewing temperature, grind size and brew ratio affect coffee extraction and perceived acidity? Compare immersion and pour-over methods, distinguish measured pH and titratable acidity from sensory sourness, and explain practical trade-offs using primary research where available.

CompleteNov 4, 202677 sources reviewedDepth Deep

Key Takeaways

At fixed brew strength and extraction, drip brews at 87°C, 90°C and 93°C tasted the same to tasters [1][4], while titratable acidity showed a clear linear correlation to TDS [6] and strongly correlated to perceived sourness [6].

  • A Batali et al. drip test brewed the same roasted coffee at 87°C, 90°C and 93°C while adjusting grind size and flow rate to keep TDS and PE constant [4], with all coffees served at 65±1°C [4]. At the same final brew strength and extraction yield, tasters cannot differentiate brews made at different temperatures [1], and multivariate analysis showed no significance for temperature or temperature interactions below four-way interactions [4]. Within the range measured, temperature had a negligible impact on perceptible sensory quality when TDS and PE were kept constant [4]. Colder temperatures required longer brew times to achieve the desired brew strength and extraction yield [1], and water temperature affects how quickly coffee is extracted [1].
  • The program collected 744 data points from 744 individual drip brews [6], brewed to three TDS levels of 1.0%, 1.25% and 1.5% crossed with three PE levels of 16%, 20% and 24% [6]. High-TDS, low-PE coffee was most sour regardless of roast or brewing temperature, while low-TDS, high-PE coffee was perceived as least sour [6]. Titratable acidity showed a clear linear correlation to TDS [6] and appears to have no relationship with PE [6], and strongly correlated to perceived sourness [6]. pH had very little dependence on extraction, slightly decreasing with TDS and increasing with PE [6], and perceived sour intensity correlated weakly with pH but strongly with titratable acidity [14].
  • Smaller particles expose more surface area relative to mass and give up soluble material quickly, while larger particles extract more slowly [32], because finer particles present more total surface for the same mass [21]. Fines immediately extract completely in contact with water [21]. Too many fines can migrate through the bed, slow drawdown and increase local extraction [32], settle into pore spaces in the bed and paper filter and slow drawdown [32], and accumulate near the filter to block pores and cause clogging [29]. Fines, channeling, poor wetting and particle-size spread can create over-extracted and under-extracted regions simultaneously in percolation brewing [14]. Percolation extracts coffee with clean water [41], with fresh, clean water added while solids-packed liquid leaves the slurry [27]; in simulation stopped at 20.0% average extraction yield, the immersion brew took more time to reach that yield than percolation [41]. Immersion brews achieve good and even extraction more easily, but are less potent than percolation for reaching high extractions [24], and full-immersion equilibrium extraction is approximately 21% over the wide range of brew ratios tested [9].
  • Experiments focused on hot drip brew and a representative wet-processed coffee [1], using a representative clean wet-processed Arabica from Honduras intended to reflect a more-or-less standard coffee [1]. Coffees with more exotic sensory profiles, such as blueberry notes in a natural-processed Yirgacheffe, might exhibit a more pronounced brew temperature dependence [1], and the drip-brewing research notes future work should compare full immersion cold brew and hot brew [4]. Sensory differences by brew-water temperature were much smaller in magnitude than those across roast level or origin [5]. All samples did not reach the same equilibrium TDS, so differences perceived by panelists may have been more related to extraction yield than to brewing water temperature [5].

[!WARNING]

Fines, channeling, poor wetting, and particle-size spread can create over-extracted and under-extracted regions simultaneously, especially in espresso but also in percolation brewing. [14] A fast, weak, or uneven brew often tastes sour because sweetness and later-extracted balancing compounds are insufficient relative to the acids and aromatics already present. [14]

Abstract

Batali et al. brewed the same roasted coffee at 87 °C, 90 °C and 93 °C while adjusting grind size and flow rate to keep TDS and PE constant [4], and concluded that within the range measured temperature had negligible impact on perceptible sensory quality when TDS and PE were kept constant [4]. In drip work, titratable acidity showed a clear linear correlation to TDS [6] with no relationship to PE [6] and strongly correlated to perceived sourness [6], while perceived sour intensity correlated weakly with pH but strongly with titratable acidity [12]. During percolation, fresh, clean water is added to the slurry while solids-packed liquid leaves, causing slurry solids concentration to decrease throughout the brew [27], which is given as the primary reason percolation is a more efficient extraction method than immersion where slurry strength always increases [27], whereas immersion is described as generally easier for good and even extraction but less potent for achieving high extractions [24].

TDS and percent extraction strongly impact sensorial properties of coffee, so experimental design for rigorously supported claims about temperature would need to take this into consideration [5]. Batali, Ristenpart and Guinard's hot drip brew work concludes that within the range measured, temperature had a negligible impact on the perceptible sensory quality of the brewed coffee when TDS and PE were kept constant [1][4], with brew temperature, grind size and brew time described as important because they affect what TDS and extraction percentage you get, not because they intrinsically alter the coffee, at least over the range of temperatures tested here [1]. Fines, channeling, poor wetting, and particle-size spread can create over-extracted and under-extracted regions simultaneously, especially in espresso but also in percolation brewing [12], with fine dust described as over-extracting while coarse chunks under-extract in the same batch to yield a cup that is simultaneously bitter and sour [38], and nonuniform flow described as capable of producing a respectable overall extraction yield while still extracting different regions of the bed unevenly [30].

Finer particles present more total surface for the same mass and collectively extract faster [21], with fine grind described as more surface area and faster extraction but too fine causing bitterness and channeling [11], while coarse grind gives less surface area and slower extraction with too coarse causing sourness and weak flavor [11]; fines immediately extract completely on contact with water [21], and swelling grains and fines migrating into a tight layer above the filter act on the bed itself [25], where a filter partway blinded by migrated fines, though a fraction of a millimetre thick, can come to rival or exceed the resistance of the whole bed above it [25]. During most of the brewing cycle fresh, clean water is added while solids-packed liquid leaves so slurry solids concentration decreases throughout the brew [27], with slurry water replaced with cleaner water forcing extraction speed to remain high as long as compounds are not depleted from the bean [41], whereas percolation extracts with clean water and immersion extracts with water gradually becoming more concentrated because it sits with the grounds for the whole brew [41] and slurry concentration increases rapidly then continues to increase at a progressively slower asymptotic rate [27], with speed of extraction levelling off more quickly in immersion [41]. Strength describes how concentrated the finished coffee is and extraction yield describes how much soluble material was removed, so a strong beverage can be under-extracted and a weaker beverage can be well extracted [37]; high-TDS, low-PE coffee was most sour and low-TDS, high-PE coffee was least sour regardless of roast or brewing temperature [6], a pattern described as possibly due to relatively fast extraction of highly soluble organic acids that rapidly extract into brewed coffee [4]. Perceived sour intensity correlated weakly with pH but strongly with titratable acidity [12][14]; titratable acidity showed a clear linear correlation to TDS [6] and appears to have no relationship with PE [6]. Suspended solids are almost always filtered out by the bed in percolation whereas they remain in the cup in simpler immersion methods like the French press [41], and French press retains more oils due to metal filtration while paper-filter pour-over removes many oils, creating greater clarity [11]. Pour-over is intrinsically unsteady with no steady state as the water level changes continuously as the bed drains [25]; pouring slower than the bed can drain lets the level fall even while pouring with no standing water [25], while pouring faster than the bed can drain makes the level climb but outflow grows with head so the system self-corrects toward the level at which inflow and outflow balance [25]. A narrow jet can excavate a deep divot so water preferentially travels through one region [30], pouring directly on the filter wall can allow some water to bypass the bed and can wash fines and particles toward the edge [30], and more movement can disturb a stable bed, redistribute small particles, slow drawdown and amplify channeling once the filter begins to clog [30].

Within the range measured, temperature had a negligible impact on the perceptible sensory quality of the brewed coffee when TDS and PE were kept constant [4], while experiments to date have focused on hot drip brew and a representative wet-processed coffee [1], using a representative “clean” wet-processed Arabica from Honduras intended to reflect a more-or-less “standard” coffee [1], with drip brewing using a commercial brewer chosen for its versatile programmability [4], including a Curtis G4 for the large volumes needed for the trained panel assessment [1]. It is entirely possible that coffees with more exotic sensory profiles (such as blueberry notes in a natural processed Yirgacheffe) might exhibit a more pronounced brew temperature dependence [1], and future work should compare full immersion cold brew and hot brew [4], where cold brew coffee prepared at temperatures less than 25 °C is widely reported to be sweeter and less acidic than hot brewed coffee [4]. As all the samples were unable to reach the same equilibrium TDS, it is possible that the differences perceived were more related to extraction yield than to brewing water temperature [5]; in that immersion work hot brewed coffee had the highest equilibrium TDS (4.27%) and extraction yield (22.28%), ambient slightly lower (3.98% and 20.74%), and refrigerated lowest (3.76% and 19.55%) [5]. They are important because they affect what TDS and extraction percentage you get, not because they intrinsically alter the coffee (at least over the range of temperatures tested here) [1], and if those metrics are the same in two different brews, it doesn’t matter what brew temperatures were used to achieve them because tasters can’t differentiate them [1].

Table of Contents

  • Key Takeaways
  • Abstract
  • 1. Introduction
  • 2. Background
  • 3. Findings
    • 3.1 Brew Temperature, Extraction Rate and Acidity Trade-offs
    • 3.2 Grind Size, Fines, Flow and Channeling Effects
    • 3.3 Brew Ratio, Strength, Extraction and Sourness Balance
    • 3.4 Immersion Versus Pour-Over Extraction Dynamics
    • 3.5 pH, Titratable Acidity Versus Sensory Sourness
  • 4. Discussion
  • 5. Conclusion
  • 6. Hypotheses and possible implications
  • References

1. Introduction

Extraction yield is most directly changed by grind, contact time, temperature, agitation, water and flow [2]. The consumers were segmented into two different groups, with about half of consumers preferring more acidity in their coffee, and about half preferring less [6]. The researchers found that TDS has a bigger effect on the flavour of the coffee, and on consumer preferences, than extraction does [33]. While higher-TDS brews had more intense flavours, acidity, and bitterness, lower-TDS coffees were found to be sweeter [33].

These pH, titratable acidity and sourness distinctions are defined in Background. Titratable acidity was the volume of sodium hydroxide required to adjust 50 mL of coffee to pH 8.2 [6]. TA showed a clear linear correlation to TDS, and under the conditions studied stronger brews generally carried more titratable acidity [6][13].

Cocinare's Temperature Control Pour Over Kettle Guide notes that water temperature controls how quickly and completely soluble compounds dissolve from grounds [10]. Achilles' Golden Ratio guide states that extraction depends on grind size, brew time, water temperature and agitation and saturation [16]. Grind, fines flow and ratio–concentration details are covered in Background.

Immersion and pour-over differences in water contact and filtration [16] are detailed in Background. Coffee ad Astra's percolation-immersion analysis explains that percolation extracts coffee with clean water, while immersion extracts with water that is gradually becoming more and more concentrated because water sits with the coffee grounds for the whole brew [41]. Specialty Coffee Association reporting on full-immersion equilibrium work notes that flow-based drip brewing increases flexibility in controlling strength and extraction versus full immersion, offset by greater complexity and expense of drip equipment [9].

Prior studies found that TDS and percent extraction strongly impact sensorial properties of coffee, so experimental design would need to take this into consideration to make rigorously supported claims about the impact of temperature [5]. The full-immersion temperature comparison used full immersion brewing for all samples, applying a 5:1 brew ratio in Toddy Cupping Kits filtered with Toddy brand paper filters [5]; samples were then diluted to a TDS of 2%, and chilled until the time of serving [5]. Individual pH and titratable acidity measurements were taken, totaling 744 data points from 744 individual drip brews [6]. Initial publications focused on the effect of filter basket geometry, how a brew develops versus time, and how coffee tastes over the range of the control chart for different roast levels [1].

Coffee temperature immediately post brew was 4–5 °C lower for the 87° brewing temperature than for the 93° brewing temperature, which is described as safer with regard to the risk of scald burns [4]. Since a cup of coffee is approximately 99% water, the energy required to heat the water represents a large fraction of the overall energy usage in the entire coffee supply chain, with at least one estimate indicating that energy usage in a café accounts for 45% of the overall carbon dioxide emissions of brewed coffee production [4]. Water-temperature recommendations and thermal stability are detailed in Background.

This report investigates brewing temperature, grind size and brew ratio as levers on extraction and perceived acidity. It compares immersion and pour-over methods. It separates measured pH and TA from sensory sourness. It draws on primary research where available and flags practical trade-offs for brewers.

The investigation excludes espresso, moka, Turkish, siphon and other pressurised or vacuum methods. It excludes roast development, green-coffee chemistry, water-mineral design beyond brief context, health effects, and equipment purchasing advice. It does not test new brews or re-analyse raw data.

Background defines TDS, extraction yield, brew ratio, grind physics, immersion versus percolation flow, and pH versus TA versus sourness. Findings compares evidence on temperature, grind and ratio effects across immersion and pour-over, keeping chemical measures distinct from sensory reports. Discussion weighs agreement, limitations and practical trade-offs. Conclusion answers the research question directly.

2. Background

Strength describes how concentrated the finished coffee is, while extraction yield describes how much soluble material was removed from the dry coffee [37]. Extraction yield (%) equals TDS (%) multiplied by beverage mass divided by dry coffee dose [2][40]. A brewed filter coffee measuring 1.35% TDS means that, by mass, the beverage is approximately 1.35% dissolved coffee material and the rest is mostly water, while an espresso at 10% TDS is far more concentrated [40]. It reports concentration; it does not identify individual acids, sugars, melanoidins, caffeine, or volatile aroma compounds [2].

The Brewing Control Chart organises those two axes [4]. Earnest Lockhart developed the classic chart in the 1950s, and contemporary discussion still uses it while calling for updating with modern sensory methods [1]. The chart’s central region spans TDS values of 1.15–1.35% and PE values of 18–22%, denoted as “ideal” and identified as the Specialty Coffee Association’s Golden Cup Standard [4]. Other summaries place the SCA filter-coffee target at 18–22% extraction yield at 1.15–1.35% TDS, dating to Lockhart’s foundational paper in 1957 [38]. Strength differs from extraction [37]. A strong beverage can be under-extracted, and a weaker beverage can be well extracted [37].

Extraction yield responds to grind, contact time, temperature, agitation, water, and flow [40]. Brew strength is controlled by coffee-to-water ratio and measured through Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) [11]. That does not make temperature irrelevant; it means temperature is often one route to a final extraction state rather than an isolated flavor dial [40]. Research on brewing temperature found that over a tested range, matching final strength and extraction reduced major flavor differences attributed to temperature alone [2].

Hotter water extracts more material, more quickly [5]. In the scientific literature, it is accepted that temperature impacts the solubility, volatility, and extraction kinetics of various coffee components [4]. Higher temperatures increase extraction speed [11] and improve solubility of coffee compounds [11]. Hotter water extracts compounds more aggressively, while cooler water slows extraction and can leave sweetness underdeveloped [11]. Lower brewing temperatures prolong the extraction process as the water molecules have less kinetic energy, meaning that they move around less [7].

Grind size changes extraction because it changes surface area, flow resistance, and the path water takes through the coffee bed [40]. If two brews use the same dose, water, and temperature but one is ground finer, the finer brew may extract more [2]. The coarser you grind, the larger will be the total mass of coffee that is inaccessible to water, which is in some way similar to also using a smaller coffee dose [21]. If the grind becomes so fine that flow stalls or channeling increases, extraction can become less even even while the average number rises [40]. Particle-level surface-area and fines-migration flow effects are detailed elsewhere in this Background section.

The ideal ratio is 1:16–1:18, meaning 1 gram of coffee for every 16–18 grams (or milliliters) of water, which ensures proper extraction and balanced flavor [15]. Lower ratios (more coffee) increase viscosity and tactile weight, while higher ratios (more water) produce lighter, tea-like textures [16]. A concentrated brew with high dissolved solids often feels dense or syrupy, while adding water lowers that concentration and makes the drink feel lighter [37]. Dilution and strength can change the sensory balance even when the underlying coffee and extraction are similar, and a strong cup may make acidity feel more forceful [13]. Strong but under-extracted coffee can taste thick, intense, and sour, with sharp acidity and undeveloped sweetness [16].

Cupping is one type of “full immersion” brew, a method also used in French presses, cold brew, and Japanese vacuum brewers (siphon) [9]. Paper filters produce a cleaner, brighter cup with less body, which flatters light roasts, while metal filters let more oils through for a fuller mouthfeel, better suited to darker roasts [17].

The equilibrium E is approximately 21% over the wide range of brew ratios tested [9]. The model predicts that the TDS varies inversely with brew ratio, but that the E at equilibrium is independent of the brew ratio [9]. The brew ratio directly controls the final TDS, while variations in brew temperature, grind size, roast level, and agitation will affect how quickly the brew approaches equilibrium, but these changes will not alter the TDS of the final brew itself [9]. Over the range of median particle sizes from 579 μm to 1311 μm, coffee brewed with finer coffee grounds resulted in slightly higher TDS and E, but these small TDS differences are negligible under the major effect of brew ratio [9]. The variation of brew temperatures from 80°C to 99°C (176°F to 210°F) does not affect the final equilibrium TDS or E, although the hotter brews reach equilibrium more quickly [9].

In the tested full-immersion series, samples were brewed to equilibrium extraction, defined as brewing until total dissolved solids stabilized and no longer increased, which required 36 hours for 4°C, 12 hours for 22°C, and 1 hour for 92°C [5]. In that series, the hot brewed coffee had the highest equilibrium TDS (4.27%) and extraction yield (22.28%), samples brewed at ambient water temperature had slightly lower equilibrium TDS (3.98%) and EY (20.74%), and samples brewed with refrigerated temperature water had the lowest equilibrium TDS (3.76%) and EY (19.55%) [5]. The authors noted that, as they were unable to have all the samples reach the same equilibrium TDS, it is possible that differences perceived by panelists were more related to extraction yield than to brewing water temperature [5].

Water will flow faster where the voids are larger, and slower where the voids are small [28]. The uniformity of grinder particle size distribution will directly affect flow uniformity because it governs the uniformity of void spaces between the particles [28]. A high-energy pour, vigorous swirl, or repeated stirring may redistribute fines toward the paper or into denser zones of the bed, and when resistance rises, the slurry drains more slowly [30]. What is called bypass is any water that manages to make its way around the coffee bed, or most of the coffee bed, and will therefore not participate in extraction [24].

Coffee pH tends to fall between 4.5 and 6, depending on many factors including roast and brewing [6]. One drip-coffee programme titrated 50 mL samples with sodium hydroxide to pH 8.2 [6], while a roast-profile study titrated 40 mL brews with sodium hydroxide to pH 8.2 [14]. TA captures neutralisable acid load more directly than pH and therefore often tracks perceived sourness more closely [12].

A 2021 study in ACS Food Science & Technology tested drip coffees across multiple roast levels, brew strengths, extraction yields, and brewing temperatures and found perceived sour intensity correlated weakly with pH but strongly with titratable acidity [14]. Titratable acidity also showed a clear linear correlation with TDS, with higher TDS producing higher titratable acidity [6]. TA tracked TDS under the conditions studied, so stronger brews generally carried more TA [13]. Brew pH showed very little dependence on extraction, slightly decreasing with TDS and increasing with percent extraction [6].

Acid composition shifts with roast degree [14]. Citric, malic, and chlorogenic acids decreased systematically as roast degree increased, while acetic, lactic, phosphoric, quinic, and glycolic acids increased [14]. Across the tested profiles, TA rose during roasting, peaked around first crack, and then declined toward its starting level by second crack, in work conducted with a 5-kilogram commercial drum roaster [14]. Citric and acetic acid will contribute strongly to the sourness of the coffee, while quinic acid is more bitter than sour [6]. Yet when brewed coffee was spiked with average concentrations of selected acids, tasters did not significantly recognize the individual acids as distinct identities [14]. A lemon descriptor does not prove a specific concentration of citric acid; a flavor descriptor is evidence of perception, not a chemical assay [14].

Taken together, [8] and [5] indicate hot and cold brewing differ in chemistry and sensory profile, but the reported temperature effects were much smaller in magnitude than differences across roast level or origin [5]. This research found hot coffee extracts to have larger measures of titratable acidity, indicating higher concentrations of extracted acids and/or additional acidic compounds not found in the cold brew coffee extracts [8]. Varying the temperature of the extraction water did not result in distinguishable pH values between hot and cold brew coffees [8]. In a full-immersion comparison, the cold brewed coffee consistently had a slightly higher pH, or was less acidic, than the samples brewed with hot water [5]. The panelists’ increased perception of sourness in the hot brewed coffee also correlates with the pH measurements we took, which found a lower pH in hot brewed coffee and a higher pH in cold brewed coffee [5]. Hot brewed coffee was perceived to be more “bitter,” “sour,” and “rubbery”; cold brewed coffee, more “floral” [5], in samples diluted to a TDS of 2% and chilled until the time of serving [5]. Although sensorial differences were found when comparing the temperature of the brewing water, these were much smaller in magnitude than those found when the same results were reviewed for differences across roast level or origin [5].

As described elsewhere in this section, controlled drip experiments held TDS and PE constant while varying brew temperature [4]. Univariate analysis showed only one of 31 tested attributes (Nutty) had significant differences based on brew temperature, with only a very slight increase at the 90 °C water temperature [4]. That difference in means was only one point on a scale out of 100 [4]. Colder temperatures required longer brew times to achieve the desired brew strength and extraction yield [1].

Sour, citrus, berry and fermented flavours increased strongly with TDS but had a negative correlation with PE [4]. High TDS, low PE coffee was most sour regardless of roast or brewing temperature, while low TDS, high PE coffee was perceived as least sour, observed regardless of brew temperature or roast level [6]. With titratable acidity, there is still the same relationship with TDS, but the dependence on PE is much lower—a high TDS, high PE coffee will not be significantly less acidic than a high TDS, low PE coffee [6]. Grinding and contact time were statistically significant (p < 0.05) for pH and total titratable acidity (TA), while the type of specialty coffee used was only statistically significant (p < 0.05) for pH and TA [3]. Several acids such as acetic, formic, malic, lactic and phosphoric, along with quinic and chlorogenic acids, have been detected in coffee brews [3]. Some of these can be extracted very efficiently in the initial seconds because their solubility increases with temperature, which could be why the hot brews exhibited higher TA values than the cold brews [3].

Adding a small amount of water can soften acidity intensity without changing what was extracted from the grounds [14]. If a small dilution improves balance, concentration was part of the issue, which is one reason tasting strength and extraction as separate variables is so valuable [13]. Alkalinity can neutralize some acidic species and change how prominently acidity presents, while mineral composition also influences extraction and texture [14]. Effectively, the perceived acidity of a given coffee beverage corresponds to the amount of acids extracted from the coffee minus the amount of alkalinity from the water [36]. An immersion cold brew in a reusable mesh bag, a paper-filtered iced drip coffee, or an iced Americano, even at the same strength, would likely have different sensory profiles [5].

3. Findings

3.1 Brew Temperature, Extraction Rate and Acidity Trade-offs

When TDS and PE were kept constant, temperature had a negligible impact on the perceptible sensory quality of the brewed coffee within the range measured [4]. The study brewed the same roasted coffee at three water temperatures (87°C, 90°C and 93°C), adjusting grind size and flow rate as needed to yield brews at the same TDS and PE, such that TDS, PE and brew temperature were all independent factors [4][1]. The work is the Scientific Reports paper titled ‘Brew temperature, at fixed brew strength and extraction, has little impact on the sensory profile of drip brew coffee’ [1]. If those metrics are the same in two different brews, it doesn’t matter what brew temperatures were used to achieve them because tasters can’t differentiate them [1]. Multivariate analysis of variance showed no significance based on temperature or temperature interactions at any level less than 4-way interactions [4]. The researchers reported that going several degrees below the 92°C Gold Cup minimum was expected to provide a noticeable impact on the sensory profile and were surprised when it didn’t [1]. In the scientific literature, it is accepted that temperature impacts the solubility, volatility, and extraction kinetics of various coffee components, but there is only a small amount of existing scientific literature on the direct impact of brewing temperature on coffee sensory quality [4]. All coffees were served at measured temperatures of 65 ± 1 °C [4]. For the Curtis G4 brewer, 93°C was the highest temperature reproducibly achievable for the large volumes of coffee needed for the trained panel assessment [1].

Taken together, [5] indicates that rigorously supported claims about the impact of temperature would need to take TDS and percent extraction into consideration, because previous studies show that TDS and percent extraction strongly impact sensorial properties of coffee [5]. Extraction Yield (%) = TDS (%) × Beverage Mass ÷ Dry Coffee Dose [2]. PE = TDS × Mbrew/Mgrounds [4]. We used a full immersion brewing method for all the samples, applying a 5:1 brew ratio in Toddy Cupping Kits filtered with Toddy brand paper filters [5]. Samples were then diluted to a TDS of 2%, and chilled until the time of serving [5].

SCA reporting states water temperature definitely affects how quickly the coffee is extracted [1]. Hotter water extracts more material, more quickly [5]. Heat increases molecular movement [11]. Lower brewing temperatures prolong the extraction process as the water molecules have less kinetic energy, meaning that they move around less [7]. As brewing progresses the concentration gradient decreases and extraction slows, which explains why most extraction occurs early [11]. About half of measured coffee components extract within the first quarter of brewing volume, while less-soluble flavour-active compounds like methyl cinnamate and indole extract more slowly [4]. Diffusion is the process that dominates in filter brews [21]. In cold-brew tests, the process variables of grinding and contact time were statistically significant (p < 0.05) for extraction yield, TDS, total phenolic content, pH and total titratable acidity, while the type of specialty coffee used was only statistically significant (p < 0.05) for pH and titratable acidity [3].

Full immersion reached stabilized TDS after:

  • 1 hour at 92°C [5]
  • 12 hours at 22°C [5]
  • 36 hours at 4°C [5]

Colder temperatures required longer brew times for the same strength and yield [1]. Longer cold-brew time is in practice unlikely to be a 1:1 comparison because hotter water extracts more material, more quickly [5].

Time to stabilized TDS by temperature

Full-immersion time to equilibrium TDS.

Time to stabilized TDS by temperature09182736hoursHot, 92CHot, 92C: 1 hours [5]1Ambient, 22CAmbient, 22C: 12 hours [5]12Refrigerated, 4CRefrigerated, 4C: 36 hours [5]36
Data and sources
Hot, 92C1 hours [5]
Ambient, 22C12 hours [5]
Refrigerated, 4C36 hours [5]

Equilibrium immersion outcomes by brew-water temperature

Brew water Time to equilibrium Equilibrium TDS Equilibrium EY
Hot, 92°C 1 hour [5] 4.27% [5] 22.28% [5]
Ambient, 22°C 12 hours [5] 3.98% [5] 20.74% [5]
Refrigerated, 4°C 36 hours [5] 3.76% [5] 19.55% [5]

Hot finished highest, ambient intermediate and refrigerated lowest [5]. Yet variation from 176–210 °F (≈ 80–99 °C) does not change final full-immersion equilibrium TDS or E; hotter brews only reach equilibrium faster [9]. Temperature changes extraction efficiency dramatically [11].

Taken together, [13] and [6] indicate acidity tracks strength more than thermometer setting. Hot coffee extracts had larger measures of titratable acidity, indicating higher concentrations of extracted acids and/or additional acidic compounds not found in the cold brew coffee extracts [8]. Rao and Fuller reported that the titratable acidity in hot coffee extracts was larger than that measured in cold brew coffee extracts, which could indicate that hot brewing was able to extract more acids and additional acidic compounds [3]. Several acids such as acetic, formic, malic, lactic and phosphoric, along with quinic and chlorogenic acids, have been detected in coffee brews; some of these can be extracted very efficiently in the initial seconds because their solubility increases with temperature, which could be why the hot brews exhibited higher TA values than the cold brews [3]. Under the conditions studied, TA tracked total dissolved solids, meaning stronger brews generally carried more titratable acidity [13]. The 2021 UC Davis drip-brew study found a linear relationship between total dissolved solids and titratable acidity across the tested conditions [13]. Titratable acidity appears to have no relationship with PE, indicating that strength of coffee is the main driver of coffee's acidity [6]. pH had very little dependence on brew extraction, slightly decreasing with TDS and increasing with PE [6]. The pH of coffee tends to fall between 4.5 and 6, depending on many factors including roast and brewing [6]. The cold brewed coffee consistently had a slightly higher pH, or was less acidic, than the samples brewed with hot water [5]. Varying the temperature of the extraction water did not result in distinguishable pH values between hot and cold brew coffees [8]. Individual pH and titratable acidity measurements totalled 744 data points from 744 individual drip brews [6]. The roast experiment showed roast level to be a much bigger driver of difference in pH than brewing, and there was no difference in pH based on brew temperature [6]. One account states cold water extracts far more slowly and selectively than hot water, with acids and aromatics extracting poorly in cold conditions, while sugars and bitter compounds dominate [16].

Light roasts showed no additional cold-versus-hot differences beyond those identified for brew-water temperature alone, while at medium roast level panelists identified more “burnt” and “whiskey” flavors in the hot brew and at dark roast level more “woody” flavor in the samples brewed with refrigerated and ambient temperature water [5]. Panelists didn’t seem to notice differences between the coffees brewed with refrigerated and ambient temperature water, and ambient temperature water took only 12 hours to reach equilibrium TDS compared with 36 hours for refrigerated water [5]. A brew that seems muted when very hot can reveal clearer fruit and acidity several minutes later [14]. Coffee also tastes different at serving temperature because aroma release and taste sensitivity change as the cup cools [23]. Hot coffee emphasizes bitterness, while cooler coffee reveals sweetness, acidity and complexity [11]. The acidity of those C. canephora brews was very low when first brewed but became clearly more intense the longer the brews were left to cool down [9]. Controlled sensory research comparing chilled hot brews to cold brews found that chilled hot brew preserves brightness and more complex aromatics, while cold brew tends to taste more floral and less acidic or bitter [19]. That instant chill locks in the bright aromatics and acidity that slower methods often mute [17].

Too cold, and desirable flavors stay locked in the bean, while too hot, and bitter compounds that should stay put dissolve into the cup [10]. Lower temperatures can mute bitterness, but they can also leave the cup underdeveloped if grind size and recipe do not change with it [10]. A hotter brew can extract more rapidly under otherwise similar conditions, but it does not selectively turn an “acid switch” on or off [12]. Temperature changes solubility, extraction kinetics, volatility, and the way the final beverage is perceived as it cools [12]. In many cases, grind and pouring technique have an even bigger effect [10]. Temperature alone will not fix a bad brew [10]. For sour coffee caused by under-extraction, the listed fixes are grind finer, brew longer and hotter water [11]. For bitter coffee caused by over-extraction, the listed fixes are grind coarser, shorter brew time and lower temperature [11]. If brewing temperatures are too high, the water extracts more volatile compounds, as well as increasing the rate of extraction – thereby reducing the total brew time [7]; this makes it harder for the brewer to control the extraction rate, and can result in overextracted coffee, which tastes bitter and hollow [7]. If water temperature is too low, you risk underextraction, which means coffee will taste sour and astringent [7]. By controlling variables like coffee-to-water ratio, temperature, and brew time, you can avoid common pitfalls like over-extraction (bitter coffee) or under-extraction (sour coffee) [15]. Temperature is often one route to a final extraction state rather than an isolated flavor dial [2]. The familiar phrase “acids extract first” is too simplistic to explain a real brew [18].

According to the Specialty Coffee Association, to properly brew high-quality coffee, your water should be between 90°C and 96°C (195°F to 205°F) [7]. Home brewers currently fail certification if they fail to maintain their temperature at 92–96 °C, but our data indicate that coffees brewed at temperatures as low as 87 °C were indistinguishable from those brewed at 93 °C (provided the grind size, brew ratio, and flow rate were adjusted to hold the TDS and PE constant) [4]. One guide reports the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) recommendation as between 197.6°F and 204.8°F (92°C to 96°C) [10]. The same guide states “That range gives most coffees enough energy to extract desirable flavors without pushing harshness too far” [10]. As Supplementary Table S1 shows, coffee temperature immediately post brew was 4–5 °C lower for the 87° brewing temperature than for the 93° brewing temperature [4]. This lower temperature is safer with regard to the risk of scald burns [4]. Since a cup of coffee is approximately 99% water, the energy required to heat the water represents a large fraction of the overall energy usage in the entire coffee supply chain [4]. At least one estimate indicates that energy usage in a café accounts for 45% of the overall carbon dioxide emissions of brewed coffee production [4]. Decreasing the average brew temperature could thus have an outsize impact on overall sustainability efforts in coffee [4]. If your kettle overshoots, drops rapidly during the bloom, or reheats unpredictably, the cup can become less repeatable [10]. Any significant temperature fluctuations (3°C in either direction is significant enough) can result in either too many or too few compounds being extracted [7]. A machine that briefly hits 205°F but drops too quickly may perform worse than one that steadily brews at 200°F [20]. Our experiments to date have focused on hot drip brew, and as mentioned above we focused on a representative wet-processed coffee [1]. We used a representative “clean” wet-processed Arabica from Honduras that was intended to reflect a more-or-less “standard” coffee [1]. It’s entirely possible that coffees with more exotic sensory profiles (such as blueberry notes in a natural processed Yirgacheffe) might exhibit a more pronounced brew temperature dependence [1]. At one extreme, cold brew coffee prepared at temperatures less than 25 °C is widely reported to be sweeter and less acidic than hot brewed coffee [4]. As we were unable to have all the samples reach the same equilibrium TDS, it’s possible that the differences perceived by the panelists have been more related to the extraction yield than to the brewing water temperature [5]. This suggests that there might be some molecular components of coffee that do not extract at low temperatures regardless of extraction time, but further chemical analysis would be required [5]. Different brewing techniques extract these compounds at varying rates and ratios [22]. The grind size, water temperature, contact time, and pressure all play a role [22].

3.2 Grind Size, Fines, Flow and Channeling Effects

If two brews use the same dose, water, and temperature but one is ground finer, the finer brew may extract more, but if the grind becomes so fine that flow stalls or channeling increases, extraction can become less even even while the average number rises [2]. Smaller particles expose more surface area relative to their mass and can give up soluble material quickly, while larger particles generally extract more slowly [32]. Grind size determines resistance, surface area, and extraction speed, with finer particles extracting faster but also creating more resistance [37]. Coarse particles collectively extract much slower than very fine particles, because the finer particles present much more total surface for the same total mass of coffee [21]. Assuming the fine particle is large enough that the regime is still diffusion, each cell at the surface of the fine particle extracts at the exact same speed as each cell at the surface of the coarse particle [21]. Erosion is the dominant process in espresso or Turkish brews, because those use very fine grind sizes [21].

A fine grind gives more surface area, faster extraction and greater resistance, with too fine reported as bitterness and channeling [11]. A coarse grind gives less surface area and slower extraction, with too coarse reported as sourness and weak flavor [11]. Taken together, [11] indicates a trade-off between surface, speed and resistance and these extreme outcomes.

Grind Extraction speed Failure mode if extreme
Fine More surface, faster extraction, greater resistance [11] Bitterness and channeling [11]
Coarse Less surface, slower extraction [11] Sourness and weak flavor [11]

Coffee Ad Astra explains that finer grinding exposes more cells to the surface, so less solvent and less time are needed to extract everything before starting to draw out the unpleasant components [24]. Ebu Coffee describes grinding too fine as giving fine particles more surface area, which means faster and more aggressive extraction [38]. One notch coarser on a burr grinder can shift the cup noticeably because coarser particles have less surface area and slow down extraction, which means stopping before the bitter ones dominate [38]. Grinding too coarse means less surface area and slower extraction, so water passes through before it has time to reach the inner cells where sugars are stored [38]. Grinding finer means more surface area for faster, more complete extraction, so sugars locked in the inner cells have a better chance of reaching the water [38]. Water reaches the innermost cells before the outer cells have time to contribute their full flavor range, resulting in uneven and excessive extraction with bitter compounds dominating [38].

The author models available mass by assuming that only outer shells of 100 micron are extracted in each coffee particle [31]. The characteristic extraction depth parameter λ is probably of the order of 100 microns [21]. The amount of fines present in a particle distribution will have a strong effect on the flavor profile of the cup, on top of the size of particles [21]. Using a grinder that produces a very wide distribution of grind sizes mixes up lots of different flavor profiles [21]. A larger amount of boulders limits the amount of coffee compounds that can be extracted quickly and evenly [31]. The small particle produces a more uniform extraction yield because it is composed of one surface layer extracting uniformly, plus a small contribution of a deeper layer that extracts slowly [21]. Coarser particles inevitably produce less uniform extractions [21]. A perfectly uniform particle distribution will not produce a perfectly uniform distribution of extraction yield [21]. The coarser the grind, the larger the total mass of coffee that is inaccessible to water, which in addition to changing the taste profile is in some way similar to also using a smaller coffee dose [21].

Particle-size evidence comes from PSDs gathered from grinding samples (an 82-points natural Brazilian coffee) with a Camsize X2 imaging device built by Retsch Technology, across a range of grind sizes and for each grinder, including PSDs specific to 3 dialled-in recipes (ristretto, espresso and allongé) [26]. The analysis calculates the fraction of fines by volume of ground coffee as the integral of the PSD from zero to 100 microns, and plots it as a function of the median particle size [26]. Particle size distributions in the range from 10 microns to above 1200 microns are usually quite well reproduced by a three-components log-normal model [26]. Coffee particles are far from being spherical, and real scenarios have a wide variety of particle sizes, not just uniform small particles and one large particle [29]. Particle-size measurements depend on the instrument, sample preparation, optical assumptions, and how the data are grouped, so laser diffraction, image analysis, sieving, and optical particle analyzers do not necessarily report identical distributions [32].

Changing burr spacing has a significant impact on the amount of fines produced, as well as changing the average particle size [26]. A grinder prone to producing many fines would result in a much increased puck resistance for a given nominal peak, and thus the barista needs to grind coarser to compensate [26]. More unimodal grinders require a much finer average grind size when pulling a shot of espresso [26]. When dialling in espresso, dialling in the amount of fines more so than dialling in the average size of coarse particles [26]. More unimodal grinders actually require reaching a slightly larger amount of fines per gram of coffee in the puck to be dialled in, on average [26]. Comandante C40, Lido 3, Mahlkönig EK43, Lyn Weber EG-1 and Baratza Forté BG generate particle distributions that a similar analysis can easily distinguish [31]. Two grinders can both be set to a similar median grind size while producing different amounts of fines and different particle shapes around that median [32]. Conical burrs appear on average less unimodal and less uniform, although there is a large overlap meaning that one can easily find a specific flat burr that is less unimodal and less uniform than a specific conical burr [26]. Contrary to popular hearsay, more unimodal grinders appear to also be more uniform on average [26]. Larger burr size do not systematically produce more uniform or more unimodal grind sizes within this sample, with burr teeth geometry and coating appearing much more important as driving factors [26]. Conical burrs are often associated with broader or bimodal particle distributions, especially in traditional espresso grinder designs [32]. A distribution with a substantial fine fraction can be useful for espresso because fines help create resistance in the puck while larger particles contribute body and structure [32]. The top-rated grinders appear to be somewhat balanced in this particular figure rather than being located at one extreme, probably indicating something else, perhaps even not visible in a PSD, such as clumping or heating of the grounds, affected the taste [26]. Some modern flat burrs are indeed designed to reduce the relative amount of fines and create a tight primary particle-size peak, which can support high extractions with strong flavor separation [32]. Controlling grinder rpm and the feed rate of beans through the grinder can also have a massive impact on the PSD of a grinder, with the Weber Key grinder as one example where the PSD is affected massively by these two latter factors [26]. There is also no obvious trend with rpm in the figure above, with the impact of rpm on PSDs being very grinder- and burr-specific [26].

Beans ground one at a time are about 0.08 mm² coarser than those ground with a full hopper [31]. For a 10-gram dose, full-hopper versus empty-hopper distributions are virtually indistinguishable, indicating popcorning affects too small a fraction of the dose to detect, with an even smaller effect expected at typical 15 to 25 gram doses [31]. The overall difference on a 10-gram dose is much smaller than one click on the Forté and much smaller than differences in grind quality between grinder brands tested [31]. Grinding a single dose in an otherwise empty hopper generates a first batch of slightly finer grounds resulting from beans forced through the burrs plus a smaller batch of slightly coarser grounds resulting from the last beans that popcorned [31]. Grinding bean-by-bean generates a slightly tighter distribution, thereby mimicking a higher quality grinder [31], although this tighter distribution may partly reflect motor speed because that dose was ground with the motor pre-started while full- and empty-hopper doses started with beans on the burrs before startup [31].

Freshly manufactured burrs often have minute surface irregularities, microscopic burrs (jagged edges), and imperfections that can affect the initial grind performance [34]. New burrs tend to produce a higher proportion of fines because the imperfections in the burrs create uneven forces during the grinding process, which can result in uneven particle sizes [34]. Typically, seasoning machined burrs requires approximately 5-10 kg to achieve optimal performance, while cast burrs typically require 10-20 kg to smooth out the cutting surfaces [34]. Typically, around 5-10 kg of coffee is enough to season coated burrs effectively, while non-coated burrs typically require 10-20 kg of coffee to achieve optimal performance [34]. Espresso burrs usually need around 5-15 kg of coffee to achieve optimal performance, while around 5-10 kg of coffee is generally sufficient to season brew burrs, as the larger particle sizes are less affected by microscopic burrs and imperfections [34]. As burrs season, they tend to produce fewer fines, leading to more consistent extractions and improved flavor clarity [34]. This leads to better water flow through the coffee puck, more even extraction, and a cleaner flavor profile with fewer bitter or over-extracted notes [34]. Friction not only wears down the burrs but also generates heat, which can negatively affect the flavor of coffee by volatilizing aromatic compounds [34]. Heat can change grinder dimensions slightly, alter burr spacing, affect static, and influence volatile aroma loss, and a grinder may behave differently after fifty consecutive shots than it did when cold [32].

A conical bed has an effective area equal to the geometric mean of the exit and top areas [25]. Running the numbers for a typical 20 g dose, the flow resistance of the cone comes out over an order of magnitude higher than that of a flat bed, described as the quantitative content of the folk rule that a V60 needs a coarser grind than a flat-bottomed brewer to hit the same brew time [25]. Brew time responds weakly to grind: the pour schedule itself sets a floor of roughly two minutes, and permeability only moves the tail beyond it [25]. East View Coffee advises grinding slightly finer next time if drain time runs faster than 3 minutes, and grinding slightly coarser if it crawls past 5 minutes [19][17].

In espresso, fines can be essential because they fill spaces between larger particles and help create the hydraulic resistance needed for a controlled shot [32]. Research on espresso has quantified how increasing the proportion of fines reduces bed permeability and slows flow; the pressure regime differs from pour-over, but the broader hydraulic principle is relevant [30]. A grinder with more fines can increase body and intensity, but it may also create more resistance and a wider range of local extraction states [32]. A grinder with very low fines may require a finer nominal setting or different dose to generate adequate resistance [32]. A higher useful fine fraction tends toward more body, texture and concentrated intensity but can increase resistance and astringency if excessive [32].

Fines preferentially move towards the bottom of the coffee bed during a brew [29]. This phenomenon of fines moving toward the bottom of the coffee bed is mostly relevant to percolation methods, i.e. those where we pour water on top the coffee and use the grounds themselves as part of the filtration system [29]. Even if the vibrations are too weak to lift the boulders or cause them to jump around, fines can still clog the pores of the coffee filter [29]. Using vibration to re-organize the coffee bed without clogging the filter would require both the coffee particle distribution to be very even, and the filter pores to also be very even and smaller than the coffee particles [29]. The wall angles of a conical brewer could probably be chosen to minimize any displacement, and very smooth edges could also achieve this, but it seems implausible to have a very smooth, frictionless paper filter [29].

A harmonic mean is pulled toward the smaller value: a filter partway blinded by migrated fines, though a fraction of a millimetre thick, can come to rival or exceed the resistance of the whole bed above it [25]. A fresh, open filter adds only about 15% to τ, but where migrated fines have partly blinded it, at k_f = 10^{-13} m² the paper accounts for 95% of the total resistance [25]. Swelling grains and fines migrating into a tight layer above the filter act on the bed itself, but the filter is a candidate too [25]. The accumulation of fines near the filter that holds the coffee bed together might get enough of its pores blocked to cause clogging [29]. When a filter clogs, it will slow down the flow of water in a poorly controlled way, and this will also result in a less evenly distributed flow and therefore extraction through the coffee bed [29]. The related drip-rate and uneven-flow consequences are covered elsewhere in this section.

The V60 design makes it extremely robust against clogging because it has a gigantic, cone-shaped surface area of filter that is well lifted from the dripper walls by ridges, but doing so makes the V60 extremely vulnerable to bypass [24]. Having water pass through a large surface area of paper filter is one great way of reducing clogging, as well as using thicker paper filters, while using creped filters with rippled surface increases the surface area [24]. A Kalita Wave is more forgiving if pouring is inconsistent, since its flat bed resists channeling [17]. Conical brewers partly make up for bottom under-extraction by having a larger amount of water pass through the bottom of the coffee bed because of their geometry, but this is an imperfect solution because the bottom still extracts in a different way [29].

More movement can improve wetting and mixing, but it can also disturb a stable bed, redistribute small particles, slow drawdown, and amplify channeling once the filter begins to clog [30]. A high-energy pour, vigorous swirl, or repeated stirring may redistribute fines toward the paper or into denser zones of the bed, and when resistance rises, the slurry drains more slowly [30]. A bed containing many fines can react very differently to the same swirl or high pour than a narrow, relatively uniform particle distribution [30]. Swirling can also increase drawdown resistance if it mobilizes fines toward the filter, so a swirl that improves one coffee can stall another, especially when the grinder produces a broad particle distribution or the coffee is unusually brittle [30]. That extra contact time can increase extraction, but if the slowdown is caused by uneven clogging rather than a uniformly finer grind, the flavor may become less predictable [30]. If a deep divot forms beneath a narrow jet, water can preferentially travel through one region [30]. Tapping either a conical or cylindrical filter will contribute to clogging the filter, and fines small enough to penetrate the pores of the paper filter will get stuck in it, so any kind of motion that brings more fines in the vicinity of the filter will contribute [29]. By causing enough agitation to force even the deeper parts of the coffee bed to encounter fresh water, agitation increases the efficiency of extraction before much of the water can actually get around, but too much agitation can allow coffee fines to get trapped in a paper filter, and cause clogging [24]. Agitation can redistribute fines, increase migration, and alter drawdown, so the same grinder can behave differently under a gentle low-agitation recipe versus an aggressive swirling and stirring approach [32].

Water flows faster where voids are larger, and slower where voids are small [28]. More uniform particle size distribution governs more uniform void spaces and therefore more uniform water flow [28]. Filter clogging that does not happen everywhere at once makes flow less uniform because it will only pass where the filter was not clogged, and poor blooming that leaves dry spots reduces uniformity because dry coffee is more hydrophobic than wet coffee [28]. Blooming the coffee bed properly to start percolation after it is entirely wet, and using a grinder that produces a more even particle size distribution, improve uniformity, while for a fixed dripper cross-sectional area, much slower drip rates tend to give less even flow [24]. Classical channels are voids where water pushed coffee particles aside, appearing more easily if particles are lighter and therefore smaller, and more easily if global water flow is too intense from applying a lot of pressure [28]. Channeling and thus astringency happens suddenly when grinding a bit too fine, even if the surface of the coffee bed looks flat at the end of a brew [28]. A coffee bed can quickly erode and channel pretty badly from excessive flow, resulting in a super astringent brew, which is partly why puck preparation became very important in espresso brewing as a way to make the bed structurally more robust against erosion [28]. A flow that is too slow, either from filter clogging or a coffee bed resistance that is too high, will make water flow less uniform even in the absence of classical channels [28]. The excerpts list a non-level bed of coffee, a non-level dripper, a very uneven particle size distribution and bad puck preparation, and state it is relatively easy to avoid channeling in the true technical sense with gravity-driven brews, while in espresso channels are not as easy to avoid because mistakes in puck preparation combined with higher pressure will favor channels [24]. Small changes in particle distribution can shift shot time, flow pattern, extraction, and channeling [32]. The use of pressure with a Büchner funnel or espresso machine is probably needed at some point, and with increased uses of pressure there is also probably a point where tamping becomes important to avoid uneven flow, while using pressure will almost always lead to a loss of beverage clarity [24]. This could explain why brews suddenly become astringent when grinding too fine, even if no channels were physically dug into the coffee bed by water flow [28]. Channeling in espresso is where water finds paths of least resistance and over-extracts some areas while leaving others untouched [38]. If the puck has clumps or density variations, water will channel through weak spots [39]. Clumps are formed by static, oils, or grinder heat, and voids are gaps from uneven tamping or distribution [39]. WDT uses thin needles (0.25–0.4mm) to break clumps and distribute grounds evenly, addressing the root cause of channeling [39]. Multi-directional stirring eliminates loose/tight zones, and gentle agitation prevents fines from settling [39]. Shaking the portafilter forces fines to clog the basket [39]. A high-dose thick puck risks channeling due to high resistance, while a low-dose thin puck risks fast flow leading to under-extraction [39]. SCA research shows >5% density variation increases extraction unevenness by 20% [39].

Bypass is water that manages to make its way around the coffee bed, or most of the coffee bed, and will therefore not participate in extraction [24]. Pouring directly on the filter wall can allow some water to bypass the coffee bed, depending on the brewer and how the paper is seated, and can also wash fines and particles toward the edge [30]. Bypassing water often touches the outer edges of the coffee bed, and may drag unpleasant flavors by over-extracting these parts [24]. The absolute amount of water that flows around the coffee bed at any moment does not depend on grind size, while how much water passes through the coffee bed depends significantly on grind size [24].

A brewer can produce a respectable overall extraction yield while still extracting different regions of the bed unevenly because nonuniform flow can create spatial differences in extraction [30]. Compensating for excessive agitation with an unnecessarily coarse grind can solve the clock while creating a less even extraction [30]. Seasoned burrs produce a cleaner, more balanced flavor by reducing the number of fines that can over-extract and contribute to bitterness [34]. Fines, channeling, poor wetting, and particle-size spread can create over-extracted and under-extracted regions simultaneously, especially in espresso but also in percolation brewing [14]. A blade grinder produces both fine dust and coarse chunks in the same batch, where the fine particles over-extract and the coarse particles under-extract, making the cup simultaneously bitter and sour [38]. Seasoning helps reduce the amount of unwanted fines, which could otherwise lead to over-extraction, particularly in pour-over or drip brewing methods where a cleaner cup is desired, and seasoned brew burrs also improve the efficiency of immersion methods like French press by ensuring an even extraction without over-extracting small particles [34]. Over-extraction brings bitter compounds from fast-flowing zones, and under-extraction brings sourness from untouched areas [39].

If coffee is extracted more evenly, then it is possible to achieve higher extractions without developing dry, ashy, ‘over-extracted’ flavours [33]. Burr grinders produce a consistent particle size, blade grinders do not, and you cannot dial in extraction from that starting point [38]. A grinder that produces a relatively tight distribution can make it easier to push extraction higher before harshness appears, because fewer particles race far ahead of the average [32]. Applying a gentle pressure (or suction) on a pour over would allow grinding a little bit finer without astringency, and therefore reaching higher extraction yields, with the qualification that this is only true up to a point, because if too much pressure is applied or the grind is too fine, then puck preparation like for espresso needs care [28]. Even extraction, meaning all the particles extracting at roughly the same rate, is the prerequisite for everything else, and good equipment allows more even extraction, which opens up the possibility of higher yields without bitterness [38]. Extraction yield, how much of the dry coffee dissolved, is most directly changed by grind, contact time, temperature, agitation, water and flow [2].

3.3 Brew Ratio, Strength, Extraction and Sourness Balance

Strength is about concentration, how much dissolved coffee is in the cup relative to water, while extraction is about which compounds made it into the cup, so a strong cup can be perfectly extracted and a weak cup can still be over-extracted and bitter [38]. The SCA's modern discussion of the Brewing Control Chart emphasizes the difference between brew strength, commonly expressed as TDS, and percent extraction, the fraction of dry coffee mass transferred to the beverage [30]. Ratio controls concentration, not extraction [16]. Strength is controlled by coffee-to-water ratio and measured through Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) [11]. Strength describes how concentrated the finished coffee is while extraction yield describes how much soluble material was removed from the dry coffee, so a strong beverage can be under-extracted and a weaker beverage can be well extracted [37]. The mass-balance link is Extraction Yield (%) = TDS (%) x Beverage Mass ÷ Dry Coffee Dose [40]. One worked example makes the separation concrete: an 18-gram dose producing 36 grams in the cup at 10% TDS gives 20% extraction yield, far stronger in concentration than the filter coffee yet at almost identical extraction yield [2].

Coffees were brewed to three distinct levels of total dissolved solids (TDS: 1.0%, 1.25% and 1.5%) and three distinct levels of percent extraction (PE: 16%, 20% and 24%) [6]. The classic Coffee Brewing Control chart was originally developed by Earnest Lockhart in the 1950s and is described as outdated and needing to be updated using modern sensory science methodologies [1]. Sensory qualities of brewed coffee are known to be strongly correlated with strength, measured as TDS, and extraction yield (E) [9]. The familiar extraction range around 18–22% remains a useful reference because it gives brewers a shared starting language, but it is not a flavour commandment: a coffee can taste excellent outside it, and a brew can land inside it while tasting flat, harsh or uneven [2]. Reported reference bands are 1.15%–1.35% dissolved coffee solids to be neither too weak nor overly strong [15] and 1:16–1:18 coffee-to-water for proper extraction and balanced flavour [15]. Research from UC Davis has shown that sensory preferences span a wide range of strength and extraction combinations rather than collapsing into one universal “ideal” point [30].

High-TDS, low-extraction drip coffee was most sour, while low-TDS, high-extraction coffee was least sour, regardless of roast or brew temperature [6]. Maximal sourness at high TDS and low extraction — with sweetness at low TDS and low extraction and tea/floral at low TDS and high extraction — is hard to obtain with full-immersion techniques [9]. Temporal fractionation work reported bitter, sour and smoky attributes positively correlated with TDS, while sweet, fruity and floral attributes were negatively correlated [4]. Barista Hustle reports TDS had a bigger effect on flavour and consumer preference than extraction [33]. Sweetness perception was highest in low-TDS brews [33]. Bitterness and astringency were more closely linked to high TDS than to over-extraction [33]. Higher-TDS brews had more intense flavours, acidity and bitterness, while lower-TDS coffees were sweeter [33].

Taken together, [36] and [33] indicate that strength ranges overlap across methods, so ratio numbers need context. Beverage ratios show differences of up to a factor of 10, ristretto at 1.5 versus filter at 15 [36]. A ‘very strong’ filter coffee would be the same strength as a ‘very weak’ moka pot [33]. Reported baselines include a home-espresso baseline of 18 g dose yielding 36–40 g at about 1:2 to 1:2.2 in 25–30 seconds from pump on to final yield [35], and a sea-level pour-over baseline of 1:15 to 1:16 with 20 g coffee to 300–320 g water [35]. High-mountain pour-over uses 1:14.5 to 1:15 for more body and sweetness [35]. Flash brew targets a final ratio of about 1:15 to 1:17, coffee to total liquid [19]. Espresso extraction happens under pressure and in seconds — not minutes — because water is forced through finely ground coffee at ~9 bars, so ratios describe yield, not total water used [16]. On the DE1, coarser-ground coffee tasted better with 1:4 to 1:6 ratios, whereas finer-ground coffee tasted better with 1:2 to 1:3 ratios [24]. A single serving uses 20 to 22 grams of coffee, about 150 grams of hot water for extraction, and 100 to 120 grams of ice in the server [19], while a two-serving batch uses roughly 30 grams of coffee, 370 milliliters of hot water, and 150 grams of ice in the carafe below the dripper [17]. If a lighter cup is preferred, the dose is kept fixed while nudging the ice up and the hot water down slightly [19]; for more body, the guidance is to “do the opposite” [19]. A thin cup usually means too little coffee, too much ice, or too coarse a grind [19].

Full-immersion brews at equilibrium only allow a brewer to move vertically with respect to TDS by changing the brew ratio, but not horizontally with respect to E [9]. The model equations predict that the TDS varies inversely with brew ratio, but that the E at equilibrium is independent of the brew ratio [9]. The brew ratio directly controls the final TDS, while variations in brew temperature, grind size, roast level and agitation affect how quickly the brew approaches equilibrium, but these changes will not alter the TDS of the final brew itself [9]. Over the range of median particle sizes from 579 μm to 1311 μm, coffee brewed with finer coffee grounds resulted in slightly higher TDS and E, but these small TDS differences are negligible under the major effect of brew ratio [9]. Coffee should be measured by weight, not volume: scoops, tablespoons, and “cups” introduce massive variability because coffee beans differ in size, density, and roast level [16]. If the total water poured is 100g and final TDS is 1.5%, then the total-water weight should really be 101.5g, not 100g, with a difference in calculated extraction of about 0.3% (e.g. 20.3% vs. 20.0%) [27]. In a French press, the strength of the coffee left behind in the grounds, the “interstitial liquid,” is nearly identical to the strength of the coffee in the cup, and drips after decanting would be approximately the strength of the liquid served, or perhaps slightly stronger [27]. LRR varies with brewing method: the coarser grind of a batch brew holds a touch less liquid than the finer grounds of a v60, and a siphon has a very low LRR due to suction literally vacuuming the interstitial liquid from the coffee bed [27].

Balanced brews show lively acidity, developed sweetness, medium body and integrated finish [16].

Comparison of reported cup patterns by strength-extraction character:

Cup pattern Reported strength-extraction character Body and balance consequence
Strong but under-extracted Thick, intense, and sour, with sharp acidity and undeveloped sweetness [16] Water becomes saturated too quickly and cannot dissolve enough sugars and balancing compounds. Extraction stalls early, producing sour, sharp, or hollow flavors despite high concentration [16]
Reported profile with structured, lively acidity and fully developed sweetness Structured, lively acidity, fully developed sweetness, clear, expressive aromatics, medium, satisfying body, and long, pleasant, integrated finish [16] Lower ratios (more coffee) increase viscosity and tactile weight. Higher ratios (more water) produce lighter, tea-like textures [16]
Weak but over-extracted Thin, watery, yet bitter and drying, with a hollow finish [16] Too much water relative to coffee means extraction continues longer than necessary, increasing the likelihood of pulling bitter, woody, or drying compounds. The cup may taste thin yet harsh — an unpleasant combination of over-extraction and dilution [16]
Too much coffee and too little water can choke extraction, producing cups that feel heavy, sour, or oddly hollow [16]. Too much water and too little coffee can push extraction too far, leaving bitterness, dryness, and a thin, empty body [16]. Proper concentration allows sugars to register clearly. Too weak and sweetness disappears; too strong and it gets buried under bitterness [16]. Higher ratios emphasize clarity and separation of notes. Lower ratios emphasize body, richness, and depth [16].

People in the first group (Cluster 1) tended to prefer stronger brews, and were more likely to enjoy high acidity coffees; while people in the second group (Cluster 2) preferred weaker brews with lower acidity [33]. People in Cluster 2 had a preference for low to medium extractions, consistent with the idea of an ideal extraction range close to the centre of the Coffee Control Chart, while consumers in Cluster 1 didn’t have a single preferred range, but instead preferred brews at both extremes [33]. They were similar in gender, age, and ethnicity, drank similar amounts of coffee, were just as likely to drink black coffee, had similar preferences for light or dark roasts, and were both equally likely to frequent Starbucks or the local coffee shop [33]. For example, in Milan, consumers overwhelmingly preferred the highest extraction level, which the researchers speculated was because Milanese coffee drinkers are more used to drinking espresso, and hence preferred the more intense flavours of high extractions [33].

Bypass lets the brewer keep extraction within a useful range while adjusting final concentration independently [37]. Brew ratio describes the relationship between coffee dose and the water used for extraction, while bypass ratio describes how much additional water is added after that extraction [37]. If 250 grams of water are used to brew a concentrate and 100 grams of water are added afterward, the final beverage contains 350 grams of liquid, but only the first 250 grams participated directly in extracting the coffee [37]. A conventional recipe uses 20 grams of coffee and 320 grams of brew water, a 1:16 brew ratio, while a bypass recipe might use 20 grams of coffee with 240 grams of brew water, then add 80 grams afterward [37]. Suppose you brew 20 grams of coffee with 240 grams of water, producing 200 grams of concentrated coffee after the grounds retain part of the brew water, then add 100 grams of bypass water, with the final beverage weighing 300 grams [37]. Starting frameworks are 20 g dose with 240–260 g brew water plus 60–80 g bypass water for about 300–320 g beverage [37], AeroPress at 18 g dose with 160–180 g brew water plus 60–100 g bypass water for 220–280 g beverage [37], and espresso at 18 g dose yielding 36–45 g plus 80–160 g bypass water [37]. A brewer can make a concentrated coffee with less water passing through the grounds, then dilute that concentrate to the desired strength, which can help avoid the dry, hollow, or bitter flavors that appear when too much water is forced through a coffee bed [37]. A concentrated brew with high dissolved solids often feels dense or syrupy, while adding water lowers that concentration and makes the drink feel lighter [37]. Dilution and strength can change the sensory balance even when the underlying coffee and extraction are similar, while a strong cup may make acidity feel more forceful [13]. Adding a small amount of water can soften that intensity without changing what was extracted from the grounds [42]. Very high strength can suppress flavor separation, while moderate dilution can make individual notes easier to identify [37]. If the concentrate is sour because the coffee is under-extracted, dilution usually makes the defect weaker but more hollow, while if the concentrate is bitter because of channeling or excessive extraction, added water may reduce intensity but will not remove the underlying flavor imbalance [37].

Different chemical compounds extract at different rates [21]. A more general equation for extraction yield should provide a better correlation with the chemical profile of a coffee cup, and therefore with its taste profile, but it does not capture effects like changing coffee, roast curve, or even grind size [41]. Currently, a "20%" percolation and a "20%" immersion brew don't taste as similar as most of us would like [27]. The author reports experimenting with brewing finer-ground coffee with a shorter brew ratio and states he was obtaining very good-tasting coffee, free of astringency, at both higher concentrations and extraction yields than he was ever able to achieve with his more classical pour-over brews at a 1:17 ratio [24]. Brew methods that produce a wider range of extraction yields will only allow average extraction yields around 20-21%, while a brew where the extraction of individual coffee particles is much more uniform can reach higher average extraction yields, about 22-24%, without getting too much of the bad stuff [21]. The under-extracted coffee cells will contribute a vegetal, sour taste, and the over-extracted coffee cells will contribute a bitter, astringent taste [21].

Taken together, [12] and [13] indicate sourness does not prove under-extraction, because a fast, weak, or uneven brew often tastes sour because sweetness and later-extracted balancing compounds are insufficient relative to the acids and aromatics already present [12], while a naturally bright coffee can taste intentionally acidic at a healthy extraction [13]. Fines, channeling, poor wetting, and particle-size spread can create over-extracted and under-extracted regions simultaneously, especially in espresso but also in percolation brewing [13]. Changing the coffee-to-water ratio will not fix extraction problems [16]. If a small dilution improves balance, concentration was part of the issue, which is one reason tasting strength and extraction as separate variables is so valuable [13]. Sour and thin with no sweetness and quick finish is described as under-extracted, bitter, dry and hollow with lingering aftertaste as over-extracted, and both sour and bitter with confused aftertaste as uneven extraction usually caused by inconsistent grind [38]. A brew that tastes simultaneously hollow and drying may not need a blanket increase or decrease in extraction; it may need a more stable flow pattern [30]. If increasing extraction adds sweetness and length, the brew was likely the limiting factor; if the acidity remains intense but becomes clean and integrated, the coffee may simply have a bright profile [42]. The experiments to date have focused on hot drip brew [1], using a representative “clean” wet-processed Arabica from Honduras that was intended to reflect a more-or-less “standard” coffee [1]. This research only investigated drip brewing using a commercial brewer chosen for its versatile programmability [4], and future work was noted to compare full immersion cold brew and hot brew, while espresso was noted to reach a much higher TDS than other brew methods [4]. The coffee was served approximately 30 min post brew, which may have allowed for a change in flavour compared with what might be observed if served and cooled immediately [4].

3.4 Immersion Versus Pour-Over Extraction Dynamics

Coffee Ad Astra reports a percolation extracts coffee with clean water, and an immersion extracts coffee with water that is gradually becoming more and more concentrated, because water sits in with the coffee grounds for the whole brew [41]. Cupping is one type of “full immersion” brew, a method of brewing that is also used in French presses, cold brew, and Japanese vacuum brewers (siphon) [9]. Janu Verma reports that with the valve shut, no water can leave, and extraction during this phase is diffusive, governed by chemistry rather than by k [25]. Coffee Ad Astra suspects that most of the extraction happens during the initial immersion phase, not during the subsequent percolation phase [41].

The percolation–immersion slurry-trajectory and efficiency comparison is covered in the discussion of how unevenness punishes the cup and is not repeated here.

Slurry trajectory and cup correlation for immersion versus percolation:

| Attribute | Immersion | Percolation | | Cup correlation | Chemical profile strongly correlated with how abundant each compound is in the bean [41] | Chemical profile strongly correlated with extraction speed, with fast-extracting compounds over-represented [41] |

Coffee Ad Astra reports fast-extracting compounds will be over-represented in a percolation brew [41]. Coffee Ad Astra reports the chemical profile of a percolation brew will be very strongly correlated with extraction speed, whereas an immersion brew will instead be strongly correlated with how abundant each chemical compound is in the coffee bean [41]. Coffee Ad Astra reports if you wait long enough, an immersion brew will very closely reflect the chemical composition that was initially in the coffee bean, as each individual chemical compound comes to balance with the slurry [41]. Coffee Ad Astra reports if you stop the brew before everything is extracted, the slowest-extracting compounds will be a little bit underrepresented, but otherwise the chemical composition of your cup will be a pretty good reflection of the chemical composition in the coffee bean [41]. Coffee Ad Astra reports even if water is concentrated in a specific compound, it doesn’t prevent it from extracting other compounds efficiently [41]. Coffee Ad Astra states if everything were extracted from the coffee beans, then the immersion and percolation brews would end up with the exact same chemical profiles, the brew times would just be different, and the concentrations would also be different if different quantities of brew water were used [41].

The extraction model was not yet tested against real data, assumed spherical particles, and assumed chemical compounds extract at a rate that decreases exponentially [21]. The percolation-immersion analysis was described as dimensionless (i.e. it does not involve any physical units), and therefore it does not indicate how significant these differences between percolation and immersion are; it was stated that it is not known whether they are the cause for 1% or 50% of the taste difference, with a guess of much less than 50% [41].

Coffee Ad Astra reports those are almost always filtered out by the bed of coffee itself in a percolation brew, whereas they will remain in your cup in simpler immersion brew methods like the french press [41]. Coffee Ad Astra notes that in some cases percolation also makes it possible to achieve a very good beverage filtration [24]. Achilles Coffee Roasters contrasts French press retaining more oils due to metal filtration with paper-filter pour-over removing many oils, creating greater clarity [11]. The same roaster states French press is a full-immersion method where coffee grounds remain in contact with water for the entire brew time, which allows extraction to proceed more completely, and metal filters retain oils and fine particles, increasing body and mouthfeel [16]. Pour-over brewing relies on gravity and controlled flow, water passes through the coffee bed once, extracting compounds as it moves downward, and because contact time is limited and paper filters remove oils and fine sediment, according to Achilles Coffee Roasters [16].

Full-immersion brews at equilibrium only allow a brewer to move vertically with respect to TDS by changing the brew ratio, but not horizontally with respect to extraction [9]. The equilibrium extraction was approximately 21% over the wide range of brew ratios tested [9]. Barista Hustle normally recommends using more coffee in an immersion, 68 g/L rather than 60 g/L for drip, in order to target the same TDS and extraction in the final brew [33]. For immersion brews, most people used more coffee than for drip methods, but the difference was not enough to arrive at coffee of the same TDS and extraction [33]. Immersion methods complicate measurement because a significant amount of liquid remains trapped between the grounds, that retained liquid has also participated in extraction, and more advanced calculations account for retained liquid [2]. Achilles Coffee Roasters also describes immersion methods as leaving a significant amount of liquid trapped between the grounds that has also participated in extraction [40]. The conventional immersion extraction calculation treats the liquid left in the slurry as full-strength coffee, or possibly a tad stronger, and therefore uses the brew-water weight to calculate extraction [27]. The conventional percolation calculation treats slurry TDS at the completion of a brew as extremely low, almost zero, so dissolved solids remaining in the slurry liquid can more or less be ignored, and therefore uses the brewed-coffee weight as the multiplier for the TDS [27]. Scott Rao warns that dissolved solids in liquid trapped within the grounds are by definition not extracted and should not be part of any extraction calculation, so immersion extractions may be overstated, and given rather high interstitial-liquid TDS it is arguable that percolation extraction levels have been understated [27].

Janu Verma reports pour-over beds are coarse and never compacted, which makes the pour-over beds more permeable than the espresso ones, and thus makes feasible brewing without a high-pressure espresso pump [25]. The same analysis describes the flow as unambiguously Darcian — no pump, no inertia, with no need for the Forchheimer correction that espresso flirts with [25]. Janu Verma describes pour-over as intrinsically unsteady because the water level changes continuously as water is poured and as the bed drains, which changes the driving pressure, with no steady state and the entire brew a transient [25]. In the case where the level falls even while pouring, and if it reaches zero the pour is simply passing straight through, there is no standing water, no meaningful h, and the flow is set by the bed’s own weight at hydraulic gradient 1 — the slowest a saturated bed can drain [25]. When pouring inflow exceeds outflow, the level climbs, but outflow grows with h so the bed drains faster the deeper the pool gets and the system self-corrects toward the level at which inflow and outflow balance [25]. East View Coffee advises pouring the remaining hot water in two or three slow, circular passes, keeping the water level steady rather than flooding the bed [17].

Even saturation during bloom, reducing channeling, controlling agitation and matching total brew time more closely are described [10]. The same guide describes starting with a gentle bloom and pouring in controlled circles or pulses while keeping the stream low and steady [10].

In 2025, researchers Ernest Park, Margot Young, and Arnold Mathijssen published a Physics of Fluids study of pour-over coffee that visualized a water jet interacting with a granular bed [30]. Using transparent particles and high-speed imaging, they observed mixing driven by the impinging jet and avalanche-like motion in the bed [30]. The 2025 pour-over study found that the relationship between height and extraction differed between thicker and thinner jets [30]. A slower overall addition can also lengthen the time over which mixing occurs [30].

Bypass is water that makes its way around the coffee bed and will therefore not participate in extraction [24]. Even Fellow's Stagg [X] dripper, preferred in part because it suffers from less bypass than the V60 with appropriate modifications, is not completely free from bypass [24]. Pouring at the center of the coffee bed does not avoid bypass [24], and aggressive center pours cause a crater at the center [24].

Accidental bypass is brew water that escapes around the coffee bed without doing much extraction work, while adding clean water after brewing is controlled dilution [37]. A concentrate brewed with immersion, metal filtration, or a high suspended-solids load can retain substantial texture even after dilution, whereas a very clean paper-filtered concentrate may become extremely light after bypass [37].

Water temp: 200–205 °F [35]. Flow calculations used the geometry of Hario’s plastic V60 with a 22 grams dose of coffee and the properties of water at a typical V60 slurry temperature of 90°C (194°F – this corresponds to a kettle set to boiling) [28]. Controlling the temperature of slurry during an extraction is famously quite hard to do with most pour over drippers [24]. Dividing water pours into many steps, such that the column of water never gets too tall, will definitely reduce bypass, it will significantly reduce the temperature of your slurry, and will also make your brew much longer, because the water will not be pushed by as much weight [24]. Depending on the kettle temperature, constantly changing the brew water versus keeping the same water in an immersion will have a significant effect on the temperature profile [41].

3.5 pH, Titratable Acidity Versus Sensory Sourness

According to SCA’s water-acidity guide, pH gives a measure of proton (hydronium) concentration on a logarithmic scale where a decrease by one unit corresponds to a tenfold increase of proton concentration [36]. That guide states measuring pH does not give the total amount of acidity present, only an understanding of acidity present relative to a neutral pH [36]. Achilles Coffee’s acidity explainer adds that pH by itself does not tell how much acid reserve or buffering capacity the beverage contains, how multiple weak acids interact, or how strongly the final cup will taste sour [14]. Two solutions can share a similar pH while requiring different amounts of base to neutralize their acidity [14].

Titratable acidity captures the beverage's neutralizable acid load much more directly than pH alone [14]. According to SCA's drip-brew protocol, titratable acidity is the volume of NaOH required to adjust 50 mL of coffee to pH 8.2 [6]. In the 2024 UC Davis roast-profile study, researchers titrated 40 mL brew samples with NaOH to pH 8.2 [12].

The study compared three methods to measure coffee acidity in a brewed coffee sample: titratable acidity to a pH 8, a titration curve with a Gran plot, and HPLC to detect 3-, 4-, 5-caffeoylquinic acids [45]. HPLC resulted in the lowest amount of CQAs because only CQAs were being analyzed, while the other methods account for all acids in the coffee sample [45]. Comparison of the three laboratory acidity methods reported as mg CQA per g grounds [45]:

Taken together, the study description listing the three methods as titratable acidity to a pH 8, a titration curve with a gran plot, and HPLC to detect 3-,4-,5-caffeoylquinic acids [45] and its reporting that the acidity measured using each method was 71 ± 9 mg/g, 45 ± 3 mg/g, and 27 ± 6 mg/g, respectively, where the acidity is reported as mg CQA per gram of coffee grounds [45] indicate the following ordered correspondence [45]:

Item Reported detail
Methods compared [45] titratable acidity to a pH 8, a titration curve with a gran plot, and HPLC to detect 3-,4-,5-caffeoylquinic acids [45]
Acidity values reported collectively [45] 71 ± 9 mg/g, 45 ± 3 mg/g, and 27 ± 6 mg/g, respectively, where the acidity is reported as mg CQA per gram of coffee grounds [45]
HPLC relative result [45] resulted in the lowest amount of CQAs because only CQAs were being analyzed, while the other methods account for all acids in the coffee sample [45]

The study states HPLC resulted in the lowest amount of CQAs because only CQAs were being analyzed, while the other methods account for all acids in the coffee sample [45].

Achilles Coffee’s explainer reports titratable acidity captures neutralizable acid load more directly than pH alone and therefore often tracks perceived sourness more closely [12]. The same explainer cautions titratable acidity is not a perfect synonym for total acid concentration because the result depends on dissociation, buffering and endpoint [14].

Taken together, [6][36] and [14] indicate titratable acidity tracks perceived sourness more closely than pH does under the tested conditions. SCA’s descriptive-analysis studies show titratable acidity strongly correlated with perceived sourness [6]. SCA’s water-acidity guide states the perception of acidity correlates directly with the amount of titratable acidity present in a beverage [36]. A 2021 study in ACS Food Science & Technology tested drip coffees across multiple roast levels, brew strengths, extraction yields, and brewing temperatures and found perceived sour intensity correlated weakly with pH but strongly with titratable acidity [14]. One Scientific Reports cold-brew study measured the pH of all coffees produced in the research to determine if cold brew results in a less acidic beverage [43]. Cited work by Andueza et al. and Gloess et al. reports no correlation between pH and perceived acidity in the flavor of coffees [43].

In SCA’s brewing-temperature work, dependent variables were intensities of specific attributes such as how sour, how bitter and how much citrus [1]. SCA’s cold-versus-iced sensory analysis found hot brewed coffee was perceived to be more “bitter,” “sour,” and “rubbery” while cold brewed coffee was perceived as more “floral” [5]. That analysis found the panelists’ increased perception of sourness in the hot brewed coffee also correlates with the pH measurements, which found a lower pH in hot brewed coffee and a higher pH in cold brewed coffee [5]. The temperature at which a beverage is consumed makes a difference in the drinkers’ sensory perception [5]. Samples were then diluted to a TDS of 2%, and chilled until the time of serving [5].

A study found light roast had significantly higher titratable acidity and lower pH than dark roast regardless of brewing temperature or brew time, interpreted as more sour/acidic [44].

A 2024 Scientific Reports study was conducted with a 5-kilogram commercial drum roaster, in which researchers followed titratable acidity through multiple roast profiles, sampling repeatedly [14]. Across the tested profiles, titratable acidity rose during roasting, peaked around first crack, and then declined toward its starting level by second crack [13].

Citric and acetic acid contribute strongly to the sourness of the coffee, while quinic acid is more bitter than sour [6].

  • Citric, malic, and chlorogenic acids decreased systematically as roast degree increased [18].
  • Acetic, lactic, phosphoric, quinic, and glycolic acids increased [18].

Roast color is therefore an imperfect proxy for the chemistry that ultimately reaches the cup [23].

A lemon descriptor does not prove a specific concentration of citric acid; the tools help tasters describe repeatable sensory impressions, and a flavor descriptor is evidence of perception, not a chemical assay [14]. When brewed coffee was spiked with average concentrations of selected acids, tasters did not significantly recognize the individual acids as distinct identities [13][14]. The World Coffee Research Sensory Lexicon provides calibrated references for attributes such as Sour and Acetic Acid, while the Coffee Taster’s Flavor Wheel helps organize the vocabulary, and neither tool says that a lemon descriptor proves a specific concentration of citric acid [42].

SCA's water model states the perceived acidity of a given coffee beverage corresponds to the amount of acids extracted from the coffee minus the amount of alkalinity from the water [36].

The same guide states pH is an indicator of the current state of the water but it does not contain any information about how easily pH will vary when coffee, gases, or metal boilers come into play [36].

SCA reports the impact of alkalinity is several hundredfold times higher than that of pH on the final acidity of the beverage, provided that pH is close to neutral (6–8) and alkalinity is reasonably high (above 20 ppm CaCO3) [36].

Achilles Coffee states magnesium enhances flavor clarity and fruit expression, calcium improves body and texture, and bicarbonates buffer acidity [11].

Titratable acidity showed a clear linear correlation to TDS, where an increase in TDS results in an increase in titratable acidity [6]. With titratable acidity, there is still the same relationship with TDS, but the dependence on PE is much lower—a high-TDS, high-PE coffee will not be significantly less acidic than a high-TDS, low-PE coffee [6].

That does not mean every stronger coffee tastes more pleasantly acidic, because higher concentration also raises the intensity of many non-acid compounds [13]. Sour, Citrus, Berry, Dark Green, Fermented, Brown Spice, and Smoky all increased strongly with TDS but had a negative correlation with PE [4].

Consumers were segmented into two different groups, with about half of consumers preferring more acidity in their coffee, and about half preferring less [6].

  • Low-PE, high-TDS coffees were more likely to be perceived as “too acidic” and high-PE, low-TDS coffees as “not acidic enough” [6].
  • Selections of “too little” decreased with increases in TDS and titratable acidity, and selections of “too much” increased [6].

4. Discussion

Batali et al. brewed at nine distinct positions across the Coffee Brewing Control Chart [4], using the controlled drip design detailed elsewhere in this Discussion. Multivariate analysis of variance showed significant differences (α = 0.05) for the sensory attributes based on TDS, PE and TDS × PE interaction [4].

A Specialty Coffee Association summary of that work states that if those metrics are the same in two different brews, it does not matter what brew temperatures were used to achieve them because tasters cannot differentiate them [1]. [9] reports that the brew ratio directly controls the final TDS, while variations in brew temperature, grind size, roast level and agitation will affect how quickly the brew approaches equilibrium, but these changes will not alter the TDS of the final brew itself [9].

Strength and extraction shape sour intensity (3.3) [6][4]. High TDS, low PE coffee was most sour regardless of roast or brewing temperature, while low TDS, high PE coffee was perceived as least sour, observed regardless of brew temperature or roast level [6].

Sour, Citrus, Berry, Dark Green, Fermented, Brown Spice, and Smoky, all of which increased strongly with TDS but had a negative correlation with PE [4]. At the multivariate level, there was no significance shown based on temperature or temperature interactions at any level less than 4-way interactions [4].

Titratable acidity showed a clear linear correlation to TDS [6], and titratable acidity appears to have no relationship with PE, indicating that strength of coffee is the main driver of coffee's acidity [6]. Taken together, [6] and [4] indicate sourness rises with TDS and falls with PE.

  • A fine grind gives more surface area with faster extraction and greater resistance, with too fine linked to bitterness and channeling [11].
  • A coarse grind gives less surface area with slower extraction, with too coarse linked to sourness and weak flavor [11].

The small particle produces a more uniform extraction yield because it is composed of one surface layer extracting uniformly plus a small contribution of a deeper layer that extracts slowly [21].

Method sets how severely unevenness punishes the cup (3.4). The contrasting slurry-strength trajectories and efficiency comparison for percolation versus immersion are detailed elsewhere in this section.

Suspended solids are almost always filtered out by the bed of coffee itself in a percolation brew, whereas they will remain in the cup in simpler immersion brew methods like the french press [41].

The under-extracted coffee cells will contribute a vegetal, sour taste, and the over-extracted coffee cells will contribute a bitter, astringent taste [21].

A 2021 study in ACS Food Science & Technology tested drip coffees across multiple roast levels, brew strengths, extraction yields, and brewing temperatures and found that perceived sour intensity correlated weakly with pH but strongly with titratable acidity [14]. They also found that TA tracked total dissolved solids under the conditions studied, meaning stronger brews generally carried more titratable acidity [14].

Two solutions can therefore share a similar pH while requiring different amounts of base to neutralize their acidity [14]. What pH does not tell you by itself is how much acid reserve or buffering capacity the beverage contains, how multiple weak acids interact, or how strongly the final cup will taste sour [14].

Effectively, the perceived acidity of a given coffee beverage corresponds to the amount of acids extracted from the coffee minus the amount of alkalinity from the water [36]. It is far more important to keep alkalinity within a certain range than pH when it comes to choosing a water for coffee extraction [36]. The impact of alkalinity is several hundredfold times higher than that of pH on the final acidity of the beverage, provided that pH is close to neutral (6–8) and alkalinity is above 20 ppm CaCO3 [36].

This research found hot coffee extracts to have larger measures of titratable acidity, indicating higher concentrations of extracted acids and/or additional acidic compounds not found in the cold brew coffee extracts [8]. Varying the temperature of the extraction water did not result in distinguishable pH values between hot and cold brew coffees [8]. Work by Andueza et al. and Gloess et al. both report there is no correlation between pH and perceived acidity in the flavor of coffees [43].

A frequently cited contrast is that cold brew coffee prepared at temperatures less than 25 °C is widely reported to be sweeter and less acidic than hot brewed coffee [4].

In full-immersion tests using a 5:1 brew ratio in Toddy Cupping Kits with paper filters, then diluted to a TDS of 2% and served chilled [5], hot brewed coffee was perceived to be more “bitter,” “sour,” and “rubbery” while cold brewed coffee was perceived as more “floral” [5], with increased perception of sourness in the hot brewed coffee correlating with lower measured pH in hot brewed coffee and higher pH in cold brewed coffee [5].

The hot brewed coffee had the highest equilibrium TDS (4.27%) and extraction yield (22.28%), compared with slightly lower equilibrium TDS (3.98%) and EY (20.74%) for ambient water and the lowest equilibrium TDS (3.76%) and EY (19.55%) for refrigerated water [5]. Hotter water extracts more material, more quickly [5].

Several acids such as acetic, formic, malic, lactic and phosphoric, along with quinic and chlorogenic acids, have been detected in coffee brews, and some of these can be extracted very efficiently in the initial seconds because their solubility increases with temperature, which could be why the hot brews exhibited higher TA values than the cold brews [3]. Vendor guidance states that if a coffee tastes sour or thin, to go slightly hotter or grind finer [10].

The cold-versus-hot study suggests that there might be some molecular components of coffee that do not extract at low temperatures regardless of extraction time, but further chemical analysis would be required [5]. As the samples were unable to reach the same equilibrium TDS, it is possible that the differences perceived by the panelists were more related to the extraction yield than to the brewing water temperature [5].

Taken together, [5] and [4] indicate limits on attributing these differences to temperature alone:

  • when the same roasted coffee was brewed at 87 °C, 90 °C and 93 °C while adjusting grind size and flow rate to keep TDS and PE constant [4], multivariate analysis showed no significance based on temperature or temperature interactions at any level less than 4-way interactions [4]
  • only one of 31 tested attributes (Nutty) had significant differences based on brew temperature [4], with that difference in means only one point on a scale out of 100 [4]

Variation of brew temperatures from 80 °C to 99 °C does not affect the final equilibrium TDS or E in full immersion, although hotter brews reach equilibrium more quickly [9]. Sensory differences when comparing the temperature of the brewing water were much smaller in magnitude than those found when reviewing the same results for differences across roast level or origin [5].

Equilibrium TDS by brew-water temperature

Full-immersion equilibrium strength for hot, ambient and refrigerated water

Equilibrium TDS by brew-water temperature01.06752.1353.20254.27% TDSHot waterHot water: 4.27 % TDS [5]4.27Ambient waterAmbient water: 3.98 % TDS [5]3.98Refrigerated waterRefrigerated water: 3.76 % TDS [5]3.76
Data and sources
Hot water4.27 % TDS [5]
Ambient water3.98 % TDS [5]
Refrigerated water3.76 % TDS [5]

Evidence remains narrow. The fixed-strength drip work investigated drip brewing using a commercial brewer chosen for its versatile programmability [4], using a representative “clean” wet-processed Arabica from Honduras that was intended to reflect a more-or-less “standard” coffee [1].

Its experiments to date have focused on hot drip brew [1], with future work noted to compare full immersion cold brew and hot brew and with espresso described as reaching a much higher TDS than other brew methods and likely much more sensitive to temperature [4]. It is described as entirely possible that coffees with more exotic sensory profiles (such as blueberry notes in a natural processed Yirgacheffe) might exhibit a more pronounced brew temperature dependence [1].

The coffee was served approximately 30 min post brew, which may have allowed for a change in flavour that impacts the sensory profile in comparison to what might be observed if served and cooled immediately [4], and all coffees were served at measured temperatures of 65 ± 1 °C [4].

Particle-size measurements depend on the instrument, sample preparation, optical assumptions, and how the data are grouped, and laser diffraction, image analysis, sieving, and optical particle analyzers do not necessarily report identical distributions [32].

The extraction model in [21] was not yet tested against real data, assumed spherical particles, and based all of it on the assumption that chemical compounds extract at a rate that decreases exponentially [21]. The percolation-immersion simulation in [41] is a dimension-less analysis without physical units and therefore does not indicate how significant these differences between percolation and immersion are, with the author’s guess that it is much less than 50% of the taste difference [41].

The consumers were segmented into two different groups, with about half of consumers preferring more acidity in their coffee, and about half preferring less [6], and research from UC Davis has also shown that sensory preferences span a wide range of strength and extraction combinations rather than collapsing into one universal “ideal” point [30].

A concentrated brew with high dissolved solids often feels dense or syrupy, and adding water lowers that concentration and makes the drink feel lighter [37]. A brewer can make a concentrated coffee with less water passing through the grounds, then dilute that concentrate to the desired strength, which can help avoid the dry, hollow, or bitter flavors that appear when too much water is forced through a coffee bed [37]. If the concentrate is sour because the coffee is under-extracted, dilution usually makes the defect weaker but more hollow, and if the concentrate is bitter because of channeling or excessive extraction, added water may reduce intensity but will not remove the underlying flavor imbalance [37].

5. Conclusion

Taken together, [4] and [6] indicate leaving kettle tweaks until last, because 87°C, 90°C and 93°C drip brews had negligible impact on perceptible sensory quality when TDS and PE were kept constant [4], titratable acidity showed a clear linear correlation to TDS [6] with perceived sour intensity correlating weakly with pH but strongly with titratable acidity [14].

In simulation the immersion brew took more time than percolation to reach 20.0% average extraction yield [41] and percolation was described as more efficient because slurry strength decreases during percolation while immersion slurry strength increases [27], and good and even extraction is generally easier to achieve with immersion brews [24].

Taken together, [9] and [6] indicate putting strength first: the brew ratio directly controls the final TDS in full-immersion brews at equilibrium [9], while variations in brew temperature, grind size, roast level, and agitation affect how quickly the brew approaches equilibrium but do not alter the TDS of the final brew itself [9].

Titratable acidity showed a clear linear correlation to TDS, with an increase in TDS resulting in an increase in titratable acidity in the roast, temperature, and consumer experiments [6], while high TDS, low PE coffee was most sour regardless of roast or brewing temperature [6].

Taken together, [6][13] and [14] indicate that a small addition of water can soften that intensity without changing what was extracted from the grounds [13][14], because stronger brews generally carried more titratable acidity under the conditions studied [13][14]. Tasting strength and extraction as separate variables is described as valuable [13].

Reader scenario Recommended choice Deciding factor
Cup tastes sharply sour Taken together, [13] and [14] indicate adding a small amount of water can soften acidity intensity without changing what was extracted from the grounds [13][14], and tasting strength and extraction as separate variables is valuable [13] They also found that TA tracked total dissolved solids under the conditions studied, meaning stronger brews generally carried more titratable acidity [13][14], and titratable acidity showed a clear linear correlation to TDS, where in the roast, temperature, and consumer experiments an increase in TDS results in an increase in titratable acidity [6]
Drip tastes sour or thin [10] Taken together, [10] and [12] indicate going slightly hotter or grinding finer when coffee tastes sour or thin [10], and checking grind, contact time, flow, agitation, dose, and brew ratio before blaming the roast or origin [12] Fine grind has more surface area with faster extraction and greater resistance [11], but if the grind becomes so fine that flow stalls or channeling increases, extraction can become less even even while the average number rises [40]
Priority is clarity and fast arrival at yield Taken together, [27][41] and [11] indicate choosing percolation [27][41] with paper-filter pour-over that removes many oils, creating greater clarity [11] At every moment, the slurry water is replaced with cleaner water, therefore forcing the extraction speed to remain high as long as it is not depleted from the coffee bean [41], percolation is a more efficient extraction method than immersion [27], paper-filter pour-over removes many oils, creating greater clarity [11], and at the same 20.0% average extraction yield the immersion brew took a bit more time to reach that average extraction yield [41]
Grinder is broad, technique is rushed, or forgiveness matters Taken together, [24] and [9] indicate choosing full immersion [24] with measured doses of coffee and water [24][9] It is generally a lot easier to achieve good and even extraction with immersion brews, but immersion is not as potent as percolation to achieve high extractions [24], the equilibrium E is approximately 21% over the wide range of brew ratios tested [9], and full immersion brews at equilibrium only allow a brewer to move vertically with respect to TDS by changing the brew ratio, but not horizontally with respect to E [9]
Brewer cannot hold 92–96°C certification heat [4] Taken together, [4] and [1] indicate adjusting grind size, brew ratio, and flow rate to hold TDS and PE constant [4], with longer brew times at colder temperatures [1], and then brewing cooler down to 87°C [4] Multivariate analysis of variance showed no significance based on temperature or temperature interactions at any level less than 4-way interactions when TDS and PE were controlled [4], and only one of 31 tested attributes (Nutty) had significant differences based on brew temperature [4], with a difference in means of only one point on a scale out of 100 [4]

Taken together, [4] and [6] indicate that strength rather than heat drove the sensory difference: the 87–93°C drip work brewed the same roasted coffee at nine distinct positions across the Coffee Brewing Control Chart at 87°C, 90°C and 93°C, with grind size and flow rate adjusted to hold TDS and PE constant so that TDS, PE and brew temperature were independent factors [4], and concluded that temperature had a negligible impact on perceptible sensory quality when TDS and PE were kept constant [4], while 744 individual drip brews [6] showed titratable acidity increased with TDS [6] and strongly correlated with perceived sourness in descriptive analysis [6].

Percolation replaced slurry water with cleaner water, therefore forcing the extraction speed to remain high as long as it is not depleted from the coffee bean [41], and in simulation at the same 20.0% average extraction yield the immersion brew took more time to reach that yield than percolation [41]; that analysis was dimensionless and therefore does not indicate how significant these percolation–immersion differences are [41].

Percolation was described as a more efficient extraction method than immersion because immersion slurry strength always increases while percolation slurry strength always decreases [27], with sampling of liquid from spent grounds of several v60s and batch brews measuring 0.8%–1.3% TDS when the brews were 1.3%–1.4% [27].

Fines extract completely immediately on contact with water [21], while a thin tight layer can dominate resistance because a filter partway blinded by migrated fines, though a fraction of a millimetre thick, can rival or exceed the resistance of the whole bed above it [25], with a fresh, open filter adding only about 15% to τ but where migrated fines have partly blinded it, at k_f = 10^{-13} m² the paper accounts for 95% of the total resistance [25].

A relatively tight distribution can make it easier to push extraction higher before harshness appears because fewer particles race far ahead of the average [32], and even extraction where all particles extract at roughly the same rate opens the possibility of higher yields without bitterness [38]. The impact of rpm on particle size distributions is grinder- and burr-specific [26].

Hotter water extracts more material, more quickly [5], lower brewing temperatures prolong the extraction process as the water molecules have less kinetic energy and move around less [7], and lower temperatures can leave the cup underdeveloped if grind size and recipe do not change with it [10]. At 204–205°F, higher energy for denser or lighter roasts can bring out floral notes, fruit, and complexity when done well, but can also expose bitterness if grind is too fine or contact time is too long [20].

Taken together, [1] and [4] indicate limits to the hot-drip result in three stated cases: coffees with more exotic sensory profiles such as blueberry notes in a natural processed Yirgacheffe might exhibit more pronounced brew temperature dependence than the representative clean wet-processed Arabica from Honduras intended to reflect a standard coffee [1], espresso reaches a much higher TDS than other brew methods and likely is much more sensitive to temperature [4], and cold brew prepared at temperatures less than 25 °C is widely reported to be sweeter and less acidic than hot brewed coffee [4], while the hot-drip work brewed the same roasted coffee at 87 °C, 90 °C and 93 °C [4].

Taken together, [4] and [41] indicate limits to certainty because coffee was served approximately 30 min post brew, which may have allowed for a change in flavour relative to serving and cooling immediately [4], and the percolation-immersion analysis is dimensionless without physical units and therefore does not indicate how significant the differences are [41].

Taken together, [4] indicate that lowering brew temperature from 93 °C to 87 °C can retain sensory quality when grind size, brew ratio and flow rate are adjusted to hold TDS and PE constant, because coffees brewed at temperatures as low as 87 °C were indistinguishable from those brewed at 93 °C under those matched conditions [4], and temperature had a negligible impact on perceptible sensory quality when TDS and PE were kept constant [4].

The 87 °C brew also gave coffee temperature immediately post brew that was 4–5 °C lower than for the 93 °C brew, which is safer with regard to the risk of scald burns [4], and decreasing the average brew temperature could thus have an outsize impact on overall sustainability efforts because the energy required to heat the water represents a large fraction of the overall energy usage [4].

6. Hypotheses and possible implications

Unverified assumptions. These hypotheses combine the cited evidence; they are not established findings. Citations support the premises only.

No defensible new hypotheses were identified.

References

[1] Just Published: Brewing Temperature and the Sensory Profile of Brewed Coffee — Specialty Coffee Association — https://sca.coffee/sca-news/read/just-published-brewing-temperature-and-the-sensory-profile-of-brewed-coffee-37dt6 · professional [2] Coffee Refractometers Explained: TDS, Extraction Yield, and the Brewing Control Chart — https://achillescoffeeroasters.com/blogs/specialty-coffee-blog/coffee-refractometers-explained-tds-extraction-yield?srsltid=AYCX9vI3-9y1jbF7LCTGi8u26LeuF16bLFYtixJeZOqI7kQ32wPcwiGQ · general [3] Effect of grinding, extraction time and type of coffee on the physicochemical and flavour characteristics of cold brew coffee — https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-019-44886-w?error=cookies_not_supported&code=82420d2f-fbf2-483a-9554-0e3ae4741f39 · academic [4] Brew temperature, at fixed brew strength and extraction, has little impact on the sensory profile of drip brew coffee — https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-73341-4?error=cookies_not_supported&code=564c3d06-4d76-413b-9d28-cca3ce79f395 · academic [5] Cold vs. Iced: Using Sensory Analysis to Test the Claim that Cold Brew is Sweeter and Less Acidic | 25, Issue 19 — Specialty Coffee Association — https://sca.coffee/sca-news/cold-vs-iced-using-sensory-analysis-to-test-the-claim-that-cold-brew-is-sweeter-and-less-acidic-73yf5 · professional [6] Manipulating and Measuring a Key Attribute in Drip Brew Coffee | 25, Issue 15 — Specialty Coffee Association — https://sca.coffee/sca-news/25/issue-15/manipulating-and-measuring-a-key-attribute-in-drip-brew-coffee-zwlhz · professional [7] Why is thermal stability important for manual coffee brewing? — https://perfectdailygrind.com/2022/08/why-is-thermal-stability-important-for-manual-coffee-brewing/ · professional [8] Acidity and Antioxidant Activity of Cold Brew Coffee — https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-018-34392-w?error=cookies_not_supported&code=c2c3d697-0f1a-4eb8-a719-f9508def63d1 · academic [9] How Strong is the Coffee You’re Cupping? New Model Captures the Equilibrium Extraction Nature of Full Immersion Brewing | 25, Issue 17 — Specialty Coffee Association — https://sca.coffee/sca-news/25/issue-17/how-strong-is-the-coffee-youre-cupping-new-model-captures-the-equilibrium-extraction-nature-of-full-immersion-brewing-992ht · professional [10] Temperature Control Pour Over Kettle Guide — https://cocinare.com/blogs/journals/temperature-control-pour-over-kettle-guide?srsltid=AYCX9vJJ8yOjLuzgNQALuQKb-Ho2ehZ9CLE4Qo-pqzWagAMZ5zbK1PXd · general [11] The Chemistry of Coffee Extraction (Advanced Guide) — https://achillescoffeeroasters.com/blogs/specialty-coffee-blog/the-chemistry-of-coffee-extraction-advanced-guide?srsltid=AYCX9vLOGukHIURqA62NaUEeti_HWiA3ETv2PcSN9H4zfVQKiWdZuTWM · general [12] Coffee Acidity Explained: pH, Titratable Acidity, Sourness, and Brightness — https://achillescoffeeroasters.com/blogs/specialty-coffee-blog/coffee-acidity-explained?srsltid=AYCX9vLDnkvu5wODdK4LlTG8kY0yY0iRsuWATsHAU2-hJA4t-Ih-zpoT · general [13] Coffee Acidity Explained: pH, Titratable Acidity, Sourness, and Brightness — https://achillescoffeeroasters.com/blogs/specialty-coffee-blog/coffee-acidity-explained?srsltid=AYCX9vLqdkSbZhTzuNiIbHPl196gmwQarCk0O1qWk9X7HUCpadVLqRF1 · general [14] Coffee Acidity Explained: pH, Titratable Acidity, Sourness, and Brightness — https://achillescoffeeroasters.com/blogs/specialty-coffee-blog/coffee-acidity-explained?srsltid=AYCX9vIMu8FFco2o7WOfvIZdc1oiiS1VRvdZveu-QHOR-NsgDYdgU5Dv · general [15] What are SCA brewing standards and why do they matter? — https://dailyrisecoffee.com/blogs/news/what-are-sca-brewing-standards-and-why-do-they-matter?srsltid=AYCX9vKVzdxGJcjgXyec7tI2BHuDecYAIo6Tc2z4c8cWA6xr3GKDI1Qb · general [16] The Golden Ratio: Finding the Right Coffee-to-Water Balance — https://achillescoffeeroasters.com/blogs/specialty-coffee-blog/the-golden-ratio-finding-the-right-coffee-to-water-balance?srsltid=AYCX9vKvEgWSnI7TWC8brWAoqRT0uzfonEj4VSPjrbBtmndM161bP24d · general [17] Japanese Iced Coffee: Two Recipes, Exact Ratios, Beans by Flavor — https://eastviewcoffee.com/blogs/east-view-coffee-blog/japanese-iced-coffee?srsltid=AYCX9vJSLQPQRAKP2KIOGW9jkKxPfuArk1GWx7p6wXZoSw-p2WOegtyn · general [18] Coffee Acidity Explained: pH, Titratable Acidity, Sourness, and Brightness — https://achillescoffeeroasters.com/blogs/specialty-coffee-blog/coffee-acidity-explained?srsltid=AYCX9vKlclu0swABNvmkdIoRSeWTuVyh_snGW52BIpDDjF0Qa7id6xDT · general [19] Japanese Iced Coffee: Two Recipes, Exact Ratios, Beans by Flavor — https://eastviewcoffee.com/blogs/east-view-coffee-blog/japanese-iced-coffee?srsltid=AYCX9vJ64x5yGdN2LYpWAoCtHD2x2nS4g5BRS00YX9yfpC-2miT7f7ki · general [20] Coffee Pot With Temperature Control Guide — https://cocinare.com/blogs/journals/coffee-pot-with-temperature-control-guide?srsltid=AYCX9vIkWuJmpRetsN29CT_i3eNIMGVi06RWetz6dBAGK5_MnnkEr-Jk · general [21] The Dynamics of Coffee Extraction — https://coffeeadastra.com/2019/01/29/the-dynamics-of-coffee-extraction/ · general [22] Flavor, Body, Acidity – Coffee Origins — https://coffeeorigins.com/blog/coffee-brewing-methods-comparison-flavor-body-acidity/ · general [23] Coffee Acidity Explained: pH, Titratable Acidity, Sourness, and Brightness — https://achillescoffeeroasters.com/blogs/specialty-coffee-blog/coffee-acidity-explained?srsltid=AYCX9vISs12rzAfpO5eYqTx6HnrUm3Mu-ev1KH_WjBHVXPfHIRKge0-- · general [24] The Four Rules of Optimal Coffee Percolation — https://coffeeadastra.com/2021/03/04/the-four-rules-of-optimal-coffee-percolation/ · general [25] Physics of Coffee Brewing - II : Pour-over Methods — https://januverma.substack.com/p/physics-of-coffee-brewing-ii-pour · general [26] What I learned from analyzing 300 particle size distributions for 24 espresso grinders — https://coffeeadastra.com/2023/09/21/what-i-learned-from-analyzing-300-particle-size-distributions-for-24-espresso-grinders/ · general [27] Immersion vs. Percolation: Have We Been Calculating Extraction Incorrectly? — Scott Rao — https://www.scottrao.com/blog/2017/10/20/immersion-vs-percolation · general [28] Extraction Uniformity and Channeling — https://coffeeadastra.com/2019/10/04/extraction-uniformity-and-channeling/ · general [29] The Physics of Fines Migration — https://coffeeadastra.com/2020/02/01/the-physics-of-fines-migration/ · general [30] Pour-Over Agitation Explained: How Pour Height, Flow Rate, Swirling, and Stirring Change Extraction — https://achillescoffeeroasters.com/blogs/specialty-coffee-blog/pour-over-coffee-agitation-explained?srsltid=AYCX9vIVCl2oFi1idACYNagKyTZ4RMZOcFacTaFYXAHw1yBsCZfe5Eq5 · general [31] Grind Quality and the Popcorning Effect — https://coffeeadastra.com/2019/04/12/grind-quality-and-the-popcorning-effect/ · general [32] Flat Burr vs Conical Burr Coffee Grinders: Particle Size, Flavor, Heat, and Workflow Explained — https://achillescoffeeroasters.com/blogs/specialty-coffee-blog/flat-burr-vs-conical-burr-coffee-grinders?srsltid=AYCX9vLhUbrpICB5_M4LCl1cOPK05vDYtjDOzeFPzRvEQ173kjqJ1aAV · general [33] Towards a Common Coffee Control Chart — https://www.baristahustle.com/towards-a-common-coffee-control-chart/ · general [34] The Importance of Seasoning Burrs — https://espressooutlet.com/blogs/blog-articles/the-importance-of-seasoning-burrs-a-detailed-explanation?srsltid=AYCX9vIMIuFA3nKUANjzDiWvistf2julGjzKzIlUCO0l08XJihb5GaaL · general [35] Brewing Coffee at High Altitude | Cupla Coffee — https://cuplacoffee.com/brewing-coffee-at-altitude-in-utah-guide/ · general [36] Water and Coffee Acidity: How to Adapt Your Water for Different Extraction Methods - 25 Magazine, Issue 9 — Specialty Coffee Association — https://sca.coffee/sca-news/25/issue-9/english/water-and-coffee-acidity-how-to-adapt-your-water-for-different-extraction-methods-25-magazine-issue-9-pxjby · professional [37] Bypass Brewing Explained: Strength, Extraction, Zero-Bypass Brewers, and Dilution — https://achillescoffeeroasters.com/blogs/specialty-coffee-blog/bypass-brewing-explained?srsltid=AYCX9vIex7FK7BCIrc8C2M4PDboMmIm86yg6yctylkSK6G51y32rQhUK · general [38] What Is Over-Extraction and Under-Extraction in Coffee? — https://ebrucoffeeco.com/blogs/culture/over-extracted-coffee-under-extraction-explained?srsltid=AYCX9vJ7nPQb0eCaKmQEhD5JDCl2JDidV0FnhyZYSKvB0vbtCXN7ctvG · general [39] Why Use a WDT Tool? A Beginner’s Guide to Even Espresso Extraction — https://ikapestore.com/en-de/blogs/guides/why-use-espresso-wdt-tool?srsltid=AYCX9vI9H8futtQI6kPhXQIA5wogAQ0xZrpB6H00TVxqcg16Mbq_tzNf · general [40] Coffee Refractometers Explained: TDS, Extraction Yield, and the Brewing Control Chart — https://achillescoffeeroasters.com/blogs/specialty-coffee-blog/coffee-refractometers-explained-tds-extraction-yield?srsltid=AYCX9vJ3VqibkNdwTTvHt4x9AYDMGHJsz1jgQE9EHm7cPJ_HYMiaajvz · general [41] Why do Percolation and Immersion Coffee Taste so Different ? — https://coffeeadastra.com/2019/07/16/why-do-percolation-and-immersion-coffee-taste-so-different/ · general [42] Coffee Acidity Explained: pH, Titratable Acidity, Sourness, and Brightness — https://achillescoffeeroasters.com/blogs/specialty-coffee-blog/coffee-acidity-explained?srsltid=AYCX9vKLHBaxTTr_46YPhlc6JQ466AdIzutFvZ7QqHXKQk3DzEoB-Isv · general [43] The Effect of Time, Roasting Temperature, and Grind Size on Caffeine and Chlorogenic Acid Concentrations in Cold Brew Coffee — https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-18247-4?error=cookies_not_supported&code=d4dc1e73-9f61-4960-958a-c42542df14d4 · academic [44] Sensory analysis of the flavor profile of full immersion hot, room temperature, and cold brewed coffee over time — https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-024-69867-6?error=cookies_not_supported&code=8c8e0eee-aeef-4d33-aa0f-97476c888d5c · academic [45] Comparing three methods to determine acidity in brewed coffee — https://commons.stmarytx.edu/msrjs/30/ · academic

Source quality: 6 academic, 6 professional, 33 general.